Sweet Romance12 min read
Breaking, Letting Go
ButterPicks13 views
I woke up to a lighter than usual silence and the smell of cold air slipping under the bedroom door.
I thought Greyson was asleep beside me, the small rhythm of his breathing steady and familiar. I planned to surprise him, to creep out and flick the light, to see him grumble and then smile. Instead I heard a lighter click, a low voice through the thin wood of the door, and a sentence that folded me in half.
"I know Elena's coming back in March," he said into the phone. "She told me herself."
I pressed my palm hard against the doorknob. My body wanted to run; my feet wouldn't. His voice kept coming, slow and casual as if he were naming flavors of coffee.
"It's not that simple, you know. We shouldn't just break up on a whim."
There was a pause. Laughter, the soft kind men use to soften trouble.
"You don't get it. I don't have zero feelings for her. It's been almost three years."
My knees gave. For a long breath I could only hear my own blood.
"Okay, okay. Let's take it slow. Drift apart. Find a reason to split. Keep it clean."
The click of a lighter. The phone put away. The air in my room got heavy as a lid.
I let the doorknob go. A single wet drop fell from my face to the floor, the sound like a small stone.
I had helped Greyson back up when Elena left for the States. I had shown up when he drank too much, the one who picked him up, fed him soup, stayed when he couldn't keep his eyes open. I had slowly patched the holes his grief left, until it looked like love. He'd bought tulips once, the shade I told him I liked. He had said a thousand times that he loved me.
That night I lay awake and listened to his steps return, to his tired sigh, to the soft settling of a man who had just decided how a relationship would end.
"He's... sighs," I whispered into the pillow. "Is this the gift I get for New Year?"
The next morning I left before he woke. I ate steamed buns at a corner stall without thinking and watched my life shrink into small, ordinary moments: a man folding newspaper, a woman offering change to a child, a stranger with a dog that barked at nothing. I told myself I could do this: two months of distance, an agreed fade. I would move on before he had to.
When his name lit my phone that afternoon, my fingers hovered.
"Where were you?" his voice asked when I answered.
"Home. Busy," I said.
"You're at home? Why didn't you pick up earlier?"
"I'm sorry. I had a meeting."
He replied with a short, "Okay," and then nothing more. It surprised me how quickly silence could become its own language.
The fifth day we treated each other like props in a play. He would send a message, I would reply in two words. He would show up at the office, and we would eat a lunch that tasted like memory.
"Are you coming to Belle's birthday this Saturday?" Madison asked over coffee.
"I don't know yet," I said. "Maybe. Why?"
"Greyson asked me to bring you," she said lightly. "He said he wants you there."
"I'll see," I lied.
When Greyson came to pick me up from work later that week, he folded my arm into his and carried my bag as if years hadn't ended in a single overheard night.
"Why did you come early?" I asked while the car hummed along.
"I felt like seeing you," he said, casual, and my chest hurt at the way the words slid past a truth I hadn't accepted. Two people can share the same bed and hold different maps.
At his apartment he cooked me shrimp and shelled it for me with a focus that looked, for all the world, like caring. "You always hate peeling," he said and laughed.
I wanted to trust that laugh.
When I mentioned, casually, the idea of introducing him to my parents at New Year, his face tightened.
"I might be busy," he said. "Maybe after the holidays."
"Then come the second day," I said, trying to light him with hope. "See them. You'll like my mom's soup."
He looked away. "Maybe. We'll see."
That night I put on a shelf a necklace he had bought me and went to sleep pretending not to hear the distant press of his doubts.
Days passed. I stopped looking at my phone the way one stares at a wound. He would call; I would let it go to voicemail. He would show up with grocery bags, then leave them in the kitchen like evidence and go back to whatever plan had made him call my heart casual.
One morning, I caught him in the hallway with his phone pressed to his ear. I didn't mean to watch. But there he was again, voice low and determined, speaking the kind of sentence that becomes a blister.
"I found out she can come back in two weeks."
A chill ran through me. Two weeks. The calendar I had been crossing off suddenly mattered. I had counted days like a promise; he had been counting like a schedule.
I didn't say anything then. I packed a box of his things, things that had quietly moved into my closet over two years: a scarf, a shirt, a mug with a chipped rim. I left them on his coffee table like a scene change.
"Rain, you really don't have to do this," he said when I rang the doorbell to ask about his spare keys.
"Don't call me that," I said, and it felt all at once older and truer.
"Are you sure?" he asked. "We can stay. We can—"
"Just take the keys," I said. "I'll change the locks."
He looked at me like someone watching his future fold into someone else's hand. "I'm sorry."
"Words don't stitch lies," I said and hung up.
I put all our messages in a folder and then watched myself press delete until the past looked like a blank screen. For a long time I felt nothing but a hollow satisfaction, a cold kind of victory. I told myself I had done the brave thing.
He kept trying. He began coming to my building with flowers, with grocery bags, with a small, silly ring in a box he said he had ordered "just in case." One morning he walked into the lobby with a ring and an earnestness I would later call theatrical.
"Will you get back together?" he asked, catching me as I got out of the car with a stranger's name on my lips. "Will you marry me?"
"Marry you?" I laughed. "Do you know what you said while you thought I was asleep?"
The laughter left him. His face went pale and then red and then small.
"That's not—" he began.
"You told your friend you needed to find a reason to split so it would look clean," I said. "You planned to drift."
He opened his mouth like an animal at a window, searching, and then closed it.
"I only said it—" he tried. "I didn't mean—"
"Meaning doesn't erase planning," I told him. "You used me to fill a hole. Maybe you didn't think I would hear. Maybe you never thought I was worthy of being loved. But I heard you."
He went through it there, in the car park, in full view of people headed to their offices, in front of my neighbors and a pair of kids who had been watching a pigeon.
At first he looked like a drowning man who had been called a name he had never learned. His mouth shaped "I didn't mean it," and there was a second when I felt sorry—not for him, but for the smallness that had let him decide someone else's life for the sake of his own cowardice.
"I thought you were moving on," he said finally. "I thought Elena..."
"Elena is the reason you kept the space warm," I said. "I am the one who paid for groceries and stayed up with you when you were sick. I am the one who learned how you like your eggs."
People slowed down, as people always do when two people untangle at a knot. A woman with a briefcase turned her head. A man with a coffee cup smirked. Someone in a uniform whispered, "Ah."
"This is for us," he said, and produced the small box. His fingers fumbled. "I made a mistake. Let me fix it."
"Fix it? With a ring?" I asked.
He flinched. "I didn't realize—"
"You didn't realize?" I repeated. "You told your friend to craft a clean break and now you show up with roses and a ring as if we can rewrite the months you decided were disposable."
He staggered as if struck. A few people had their phones out now, not in the old way of malice but like witnesses who had tuned between channels to hear the truth. His features shifted—first stubbornness, then panic, then a thin mercy pleading in his eyes.
"Please, Lynn," he said, using the name he'd used only in privacy. "Please."
I used the full name I had on my phone for him, the name that felt like a finish: "Don't call me that."
He thrived on public performances. I remembered how he'd coached a laugh at a party to hide the fact that he didn't know a story line. He loved the applause of friends. Now, the applause was silence edged with camera light.
"I can't do this," I whispered. "I won't be someone you keep on a shelf until a 'better' option returns."
His face crumpled. "You're hurt," he said like a diagnosis. "I didn't know how to—"
"You didn't know how to be honest," I interrupted. "You knew how to soothe yourself with plans that included me but weren't about me. That's different."
The crowd around us split like a tide. Madison hurried forward and took my hand. "Lynn, are you okay?"
"I am," I said. "I will be."
And then Greyson did something I had not expected. He went from plead to performance to collapse in waves. His jaw set. The arrogance fell away as if someone had pulled a sheet off a statue and the statue was suddenly brittle.
"Everyone," he said loudly, voice shaking, "I didn't plan to hurt anyone. I was confused. I cared about both. I—"
A man passing by spat, "You call that caring?" and the crowd snickered.
His face went ashen. He tried to form another sentence and then let the silence do the work of the thousand words he couldn't find.
It was public. People gossiped, phones recorded, a woman started crying quietly into her scarf as if this story belonged to her too. An old man clapped, not in approval but with the slow sound of closure, like a judge rapping a gavel.
Greyson's emotions cascaded: denial at first—"I didn't—"; then a flared anger—"You don't understand!"—followed by pleading—"Please don't do this"—and then a broken despair—"I will lose everything." His expression moved as if a film reel had scratched.
Madison squeezed my fingers. "Do you want me to say anything?"
"Just stand with me," I said.
He tried to take up the narrative again. "Look, people, I've been a mess. I thought I could handle this, but I'm still human. Please, we were good—"
A woman across the street laughed. "Good? You had someone living beside you, and you planned a walk-away for convenience!"
The crowd murmured and the murmurs turned into questions. "How long has she known?" "Is she okay?" "I can't believe he did that."
Greyson went bright red. His hand flew to his head. He looked as if he might bolt.
I watched him through the crowd and felt the odd, cold inner fact of someone reduced: the person I'd loved became small and obvious. There was a kind of satisfaction that rose up—cruel and clean. Not revenge, exactly. The world had simply rearranged the truth so everyone could see.
"You don't get to toss people," I said softly, though my voice reached them. "Not like trash."
His expression changed when shame hit him—the pivot I had been waiting for. He tried to speak. His mouth opened and closed.
"I'm sorry," he said finally. "I'm sorry."
I felt no triumph in that sorry. Only the justice of it, the equality.
The onlookers debated, some pitying, some harsh. Phones buzzed. Someone snapped a photo. It spread, and within hours the story had legs. Greyson retreated, shoulders curled inward. He looked at me as if the last thing he had known had been removed from his hands.
"Don't come to my work. Don't call," I told him.
He nodded, like a man agreeing to exile, and walked away, both hands jammed into his coat pockets.
Later, when I sat on the stairwell of my building and let the autumn sun draw vague lines on my knees, I realized that the punishment wasn't only being humiliated in public. The punishment was the dismantling of the private life he'd planned to use on a schedule: the community that had once backed him, the friends who clustered around his table, the small comforts of his apartment that I had thought were ours. The public had become a mirror and it showed him exactly how he looked.
Madison came and sat beside me. "People are saying cruel things," she said. "But they also think you're brave."
"Brave?" I scoffed. "I feel stupid."
"Brave looks like walking away," she said simply.
He tried to return in different ways over the next weeks. He changed numbers; he sent messages from new accounts; he attempted to show up at places where he knew I'd be with a bouquet or a contrite smile. Every time he stepped into that space, someone I trusted would be there to remind him of his public collapse.
One afternoon, at an office party where I was helping with logistics, Greyson walked in and, like a moth to glass, went straight to the small stage they'd set up for awards. He had planned a speech—he must have—because he called my name before he had a right to and addressed the crowd as if we had conspired to forget his betrayal.
"Can I speak?" he asked into a borrowed mic.
The room held its breath. Some whispered. The sting of cameras still lingered.
"I have something to say," he began, voice steady at first, then wavering. "I made a grave mistake. I misused someone who cared about me."
He looked at me. I looked away. People shuffled. Someone from HR called out, "This isn't the place—"
"But she deserves to hear me own it," he said, and for a painful second he looked like the man I fell in love with, raw and human and honest.
He told the room about indecision and confusion, about Elena's return and the coward's plan to phase me out. He apologized publicly, fingers clenched around the microphone as if the metal could anchor him.
People gasped. A colleague who had defended him before sat very still. Phones recorded. My boss looked at Greyson with a new kind of calculation.
At the end, Greyson's face looked drained. He had exposed himself and been judged by the one court that matters: the court of witnesses who knew everything now.
He left the party with his head bowed. The crowd dispersed. It was punishment in full, public and sustained. He had tried to salvage himself with speech, but every word dug the hole deeper.
That night, when calls and texts flooded in, I ignored them all. The ring still sat unworn in a velvet box, ridiculous and obscene. I tucked it into a desk drawer, where it looked like a trivial weapon.
Months later, when Elena indeed came back and they ran into each other at a mutual friend's gathering, the world shifted again in a different direction. Elena was charming and distant in a way he used to find irresistible. They spoke in fragments, like old songs. My curiosity was a passing thing. When they met again, it had the reluctant warmth of people who had once shared plate of food and then found other streets.
A few weeks after Elena's first dinner in town, Greyson called me. I didn't pick up. He begged via text. The messages read like a string of knots: "Please," "I messed up," "I wanted to be honest but..." His grammar broke. He asked for a chance to explain.
I did not answer.
Instead, I boarded a plane with Keily. We went to the sea and watched the sky bleed pink as the sun fell like an idea you hold for too long. Keily took pictures of me in front of sunlit cliffs and said, "This trip is your cleansing."
"I don't want stories to bite me anymore," I told her.
"Then don't feed them," she said, scooping my hair behind my ear.
We didn't talk about Greyson much. We walked along the water, bought postcards, drank coffee at odd hours and let the world bloom into shards I could pick up at my own pace. When I returned home I applied for a transfer I had long wanted and got it. Someone finally noticed the work I'd been carrying and rewarded it. The days filled with tasks and small triumphs—reports finished, late trains caught, a colleague who laughed at a joke I'd made.
Once, at a community event, Greyson appeared with a rose and a show. He tried again and again to place me at the center of his acts, but the crowd—my friends, my colleagues—had already seen enough. They knew his voice and they'd seen how he'd used it. I stood beside Madison and watched him divert his pleas toward an audience that no longer gave him stagehands.
"I won't be your safety net," I told him once, when he cornered me behind a folding table. "I refuse to be someone you can put back on a shelf."
He made a sound that was half laugh, half sob. "So that's it?"
"That's it," I said.
And then life unfolded itself into small, precise things. I boxed the last of his shirts and drove them to the goodwill shop. I took the necklace to a jeweler to have the chain repaired and then kept it as a thing that smelled like a season of my life. I dated a kind man who liked to share desserts and never mentioned my ex unless I asked. I traveled to see vistas that demanded all my attention. I learned how to make soup that smelled like my mother's kitchen and how to sleep without flinching awake at forks of footsteps.
The sweetest, small moments came with no fireworks: a coworker complimenting my presentation, Keily calling at midnight to announce she'd eaten too much cake, Madison slapping my back and saying, "About time." Greyson's phone calls dwindled into nothing—an occasional "Are you okay?" that sounded like a ghost trying a door.
On a quiet night much later, I sat at my desk with the calendar I had once crossed off with so much intention. I flipped to the month I had spent counting and drew one last line through a date.
"I call this my letting go," I murmured to the empty apartment.
Madison was on the couch, hands warm with a mug. "You earned it," she said.
I smiled and reached into the drawer where the ring slept. I set it down on the table. "Some things are for people to keep. Some things you have to set down."
The ring looked like the idea of a life too small for the one I wanted. I pushed it into a box and labeled it "past."
When the next New Year's came, I didn't wake to a lighter under a door. I woke to sunlight through curtains and a message from Greyson that I never opened. I went to the kitchen, made a pot of coffee, and put on a sweater that had nothing to do with anyone else's hands.
I stepped out to the balcony with my cup and watched the city wake. The necklace I kept shone at my throat, dull and familiar. I played a photo Keily had taken of us on the cliffs; the sky behind us was enormous. I realized then that the knot in my chest had loosened enough to breathe.
I whispered to the empty air, "This is the year I stop collecting other people's stories."
Madison laughed from behind me. "Keep the necklace," she said. "It looks good on you."
I laughed. "I won't trade it for any ring."
And when I crossed another day off my calendar, I added one small, private note: I had learned to leave, not because I was weak, but because I chose myself.
That night, before I went to bed, I slipped the little ring into the box and slid it into the back of a drawer. I took the calendar and tucked it into the book I'd been reading. I placed the house key from Greyson's old place on the tea tray by my couch.
"I call it my letting-go," I told the quiet room. "And this tray will remember when I stopped waiting."
I slept without replaying his voice.
I didn't need people to tell me I'd been brave. The city outside hummed, and under that hum I found a small and steady pulse that belonged only to me.
The End
— Thank you for reading —