Face-Slapping12 min read
"I Throw Your Tea at His Head" — How I Made the Whole Hall Watch Them Fall
ButterPicks11 views
"Stop talking." I slammed my teacup down so hard the rim clicked and the servants jumped.
"You're—" Nolan Reyes froze, his voice brittle.
"Am I what?" I leaned forward. "A mistake? A stain? A toy? Say it again."
"You—" Nolan's wife, Annabelle Vargas, stepped between him and me. "Giselle, you are our guest. This is uncivil."
"This is my sister's honor," I said. "You made it a public joke. I will not be civil."
They had called my sister Isla McCormick a "hen that won't lay" in their great hall. A low maid had said it first, but the joke came from them. I had watched the old housemaid—silk creased in the wrong place—smile warm as she repeated Nolan's private joke. I had watched Isla lie sick in the bedroom after someone blocked the message that would have saved her, and laugh—no, I had heard the maid laugh—while Isla nearly died. I had said nothing at the time because I wanted them to keep talking. I wanted every false laugh and polite smile to collect in the room like rainwater, so I could break the drain.
"You beat a servant to death in my hall," I told Nolan. "One of yours. And you laughed about the body. Explain that."
A tray clattered. The room went very quiet. Nolan's mustache twitched.
"We—" he began. "There are rules. The staff— she insulted us—"
"She insulted my sister?" I cut him off. "She said one line. Your wife and your daughters and your men smoked it into fire." I stood. "Your daughter called her names in front of a room full of people, and then you beat the old woman until she stopped moving." I pointed at Nolan with my teacup. "You did it and you said you were 'doing business'. Explain 'doing business'."
Annabelle turned pale. "We did nothing of the sort—"
"Shut up," I said. "You told the housemaids to hush the gossip and sent a runner to the guard. You hid the bruises. And you used me as a shield when it suited you."
A ripple moved through the hall. Guests shifted in their seats. They had eaten the food Nolan's house provided. They had laughed with Nolan. They had ignored my sister. Now they looked at me the way people look at a match: nervous about being burned.
"Isla?" I called. "Come out."
Isla McCormick came down the stairs like a ghost returning to her own body. She looked pale, but she walked straight to me.
"Giselle," she whispered. "You shouldn't—"
"I know," I said. "But they should see."
A servant lifted the tapestries. The room smelled of roasted chestnuts and oil, and of cold daylight through painted glass. Nolan tried to take control with a soft voice, the kind of voice men use when they have a paper plan and no spine.
"Lady Giselle," he began. "We will handle this—"
"Handle it?" I laughed. "You mean 'bury it'. You like the dirt you stand on, Nolan. You built a brand on polite lies."
"That is enough," Annabelle said, too loud. "My husband is a scholar. He—"
"He taught words," I said. "Not mercy."
Someone coughed. A distant cousin, Dorian Duke, who had come as our ally, clapped once and leaned forward.
"Let her speak," Dorian said. He was my husband, the man who had broken winter's silence and then told me I could do what I liked; the man who had frowned at the chapter house and shrugged off the cold. "We will hear this out."
Everyone turned to Dorian. He looked back at me, eyes like two knives wrapped in velvet.
"Do it gently, Giselle," he whispered.
"We are not gentle," I said.
"You want me to recount the whole thing?" Nolan demanded. "There is no proof."
"You are very right," I said. "There was no proof. Until tonight."
"Until tonight?" Nolan echoed.
I touched my sleeve. A parchment slid out—thin, hacked, and rough. I had a way with things that look like accidents. Fifteen years in another life teaches you to be patient. I had waited for months, learned the routes, bribed a washer, followed the tradesman who took the repair orders into the yards, and I had what I needed.
"This is their ledger," I said. "Their payments. Look."
I threw the parchment onto the table. The house steward thought he had the advantage; he grabbed it and glanced up, as if he could read and swallow me whole.
"That is forged," he declared.
"You can read, Gideon?" I asked the steward. "You can read the damage and the stamps?" He paled.
"This ledger—" Nolan began.
"—lists payments," I said. "To a man named Bram. Bram is the keeper of punishments. Bram's ledger shows one payment the day that the old maid was silenced. Look: a purchase for a 'lesson' and a list of goods carried away as 'loss.'"
"Forged," Nolan repeated, but his voice had no spine.
"Forged?" Dorian said, and the room turned. "Gideon, how much did you charge this family for making testimony disappear?"
Gideon, the steward, swallowed hard. "No one told me to destroy—"
"But you kept books?" I asked. "And hush-money receipts?"
"I—" Gideon's shoulders hitched. "We— we put things in the wrong chest sometimes."
"Wrong chest?" I sneered. "You put a beating in the wrong ledger?"
Gideon cracked. He handed the ledger to a guard. "We took money to hush them." He shook like a leaf and then he cried.
"Enough," Annabelle whispered, but it was too late.
"Do it," I told Dorian. "Read the last three lines."
He read. "Payment: twenty taels for hush. Payment: ten taels to Bram. Payment: 'cleaning off'—"
The hall filled with a sound like knives dropping. Someone gasped. A woman put her hand over her mouth.
"That is payment for murder," someone said.
"You paid to silence an old woman," I told Nolan. "You paid because your house could not forgive a servant for speaking two words. You paid because you feared the shame of a child born somewhere outside your lineage. You paid because you prefer your name to a girl's life."
Annabelle's smile cracked. Nolan's face twitched.
"You lie," Annabelle said. "You are a madwoman."
"Am I?" I stepped forward. "Or are you the kind who hires men to beat and then weeps at the loss of reputation?"
"Stop." Nolan's voice had become small. "This is slander."
"Then prove me wrong," I said. "Open your private channels. Let the guard search Bram's room. Let the household read all ledgers."
"No," Nolan said, the single syllable like a thin rope. "You cannot demand—"
"I can," Dorian said. "He can. We will fetch the guard. I will fetch anyone. If you did not do this, you have nothing to fear. If you did, you will hang."
Annabelle's mouth opened, closed. People murmured. Some felt the wind turn. They had smiled over soup and now they were cold.
"Very well," Nolan said, the colour gone from his face. "If you want to make a fool of yourselves, do it. But—"
"But?" I asked.
"But look at where this will leave both houses," Nolan said. "The scholars will be ruined. The warriors will be seen as beasts."
"We will be seen as what we are," Dorian said. "Do your worse."
They called for Bram. Bram was a little man with a slug's softness. He came, wiping his hands. He looked at the ledger in Gideon's hand and he went pale.
"You wrote this?" Nolan asked him.
Bram's eyes darted. "House— payments—" He was like a rat on a plank.
"Speak," Annabelle demanded.
Bram looked at his paymasters, and for the first time the old fear in his face gave way to something else: a person remembering that someone might throw them a rope.
"It was the chance for coin," he said. "They asked for teaching and I taught. The old woman— she said words I did not like. I was told to teach her. I struck her. She wouldn't stop. I struck more. I struck until—"
He looked away. The room filled with a sick silence so that you could hear the fire stop noting its own flame.
"You did this?" Nolan asked.
Bram nodded, like a man admitting the weather.
"Who told you?" Dorian asked.
"Lady Annabelle," Bram said. "Lady Annabelle said the insult would be a stain. She said pay the man and the stain will be buried. I took money. The house paid Bram. The ledger is old, but the marks are true."
Annabelle's colour drained. She made a small sound—a baby's sound—and then she collapsed into a chair as if struck. People in the hall whispered like a swarm.
"You think this is a joke," I said. "You thought you could maim a woman and the town would close the door. You thought a ledger covers a life. You thought the world wouldn't care."
Nolan ran his hand through his hair. "We were— we were protecting the family's honor."
"Your honor?" I scoffed. "Your honor costs money? Your honor is a ledger line? Your honor ate a woman's breath."
He seemed smaller than before. A weak man in silk.
"Call the guard," I told Dorian. "Arrest Bram. Bring Nolan's private chest. Search the house. Let the city see their wealth. Let them see how they buy silence."
"There are laws," Nolan croaked.
"Good," I said. "Let's use them."
Guards were called. Bram was taken. Gideon confessed more. The ledger spread open on a table like an ugly flower. People read the numbers. They read the dates. They read purchases for "delicate handling" and "quiet boxes." A woman fanned herself and then stopped.
"Shame," she whispered.
That night the story spread. The guards marched Nolan Reyes' keepers. They took Bram to the common hall to be judged. I stayed where I was as guests fled or stood in stunned groups like sheep.
"You wanted them to be destroyed," Dorian said quietly at my side.
"No," I answered. "I wanted them to be seen."
Dorian put his hand on my wrist. "They will fall."
"They should," I said.
A week later came the public punishment.
"We are at the market square," I said. "There are banners. The day is bright. The cold is sharp."
"Is this necessary?" Isla asked, her voice a thin reed.
"It is," I said. "They will be punished in public. They must bow to the shame they dispensed."
We stood at the edge of the square as an enormous crowd assembled. Nolan was called to the center, his carriage halted near the scaffold. Annabelle's white hands trembled. Their daughters—two pale girls who had been sneering from the start—stood wrapped in furs but not faking shame.
"Bram!" the captain called. "Stand!"
Bram was brought out with rope and a stained shirt. He walked like a man who had already been stripped of dignity.
"Nolan Reyes!" the captain cried. "By order of the magistrate, you will answer for your house's crimes."
Nolan looked around for support but faces turned away. Men who had once laughed with him now kept their breath. Dorian stood with me, hands folded, even though our life would never be the same after this.
"This is not ours," Nolan said. "We—"
"You paid for silence," someone shouted. "You bought murder."
"It wasn't—" Nolan's voice broke.
Annabelle sank to her knees. "Please," she cried. "I did not—"
"Silence!" a voice cut through. "All of you who took money, step forward."
Gideon stepped out. He had not yet been punished; his guilt was raw and he wanted the crowd to decide.
"I kept the books," Gideon said. "I took money. I let them be written as 'losses.' I am guilty."
A few other servants stepped forward as the truth rolled like a wave. The crowd's murmurs turned to a roar. Voices called for blood. A woman threw a dish and hit the guard's boot; she did not stop.
"Your house told the maid to keep silent," the magistrate said to Nolan. "Your house paid for it. The law will decide the cost."
"What cost?" Nolan whispered.
The magistrate tapped the ledger. "You will pay all the hush-money. You will deliver it for the support of the maid's family. You will open your doors to inspection. Your household staff will be tested for further crimes. Your heads of house will be punished."
"Punish me," Nolan said suddenly. "I will pay. I will—"
"You will not be allowed to rebuild your honor with money," I said. "You must stand where your cruelty put others. You will be shamed— publicly. Your sons will not inherit until you have shown repentance."
The crowd hissed and cheered at once. Someone held up a scrap with Bram's confession. The magistrate nodded.
"Then let it be so," he said. "Nolan Reyes, you will be required to stand on the scaffolding for three days baring your name to the crowd. Your wife Annabelle will be made to apologize publicly three times a day. Your two daughters will be paraded and given the duty of public service to the maid's village. Bram will be stripped of his position and sent to the brig for three years—"
Bram's eyes bulged; he began to cry.
"And you," the magistrate said, eyes flicking to Nolan, "for instigating violence, you will be strapped and made to wear a sign bearing the words 'I bought silence' for three days in the market. Your coffers will be opened in the market and the people will take what you owe. Let the town judge."
Nolan looked like a crumbling statue. A man who had once purchased influence now had to purchase mercy with the very things he had hoarded.
"Please," Annabelle begged. "Our children—"
"Child or not," the magistrate said, "the debt is paid by the house."
The crowd began to chant. Songs turned to jeers. Some women spat. Cameras—no, scribes—scribbled. Servants who had felt the lash took chestfuls of sunlight and began to cheer. People had a taste for some balance.
"Beg!" someone shouted. "Beg!"
Nolan dropped to his knees. He was a big man in a small puddle of shame. He flailed: "Please! I am sorry! I didn't want blood! I just—"
A mob began to gather. Nolan's face crumpled. He reached for something—anything—and found only air.
"Take his sign," I told the magistrate.
They took it and nailed it to his chest. The letters were blunt and cruel: I BOUGHT SILENCE.
"Look!" someone cried. "He bought death."
Nolan's daughters wept. One tried to rush into their carriage and was stopped by a guard. The crowd snapped like a net. People circled Nolan with torches of scorn.
"Are you sorry?" a woman demanded. "Are you sorry now that your ledger is open?"
Nolan made a sound and his knees scraped on cobbles. He had known privilege. He had not known public hunger.
"Forgive me," he said, voice small. "Forgive—"
"Get on your feet," someone yelled. "You get no forgiveness if you don't face us."
Nolan stood. He was shaking.
"Now," the magistrate said, "Annabelle, step forward and apologize in three clear words to the maid's family."
Annabelle gulped as if swallowing a stone. She went to the family of the dead woman—small, poor, ragged—and bowed.
"I am sorry," she said. "I am sorry. I am sorry."
People recorded the three apologies on scraps and chanted them. Her voice wavered and then broke. She tried to say more excuses but the crowd would have none.
"Next!" the magistrate said. "Bring forward their ledger of donations to the market for the poor."
Ledgers were brought and the crowd peeled off coin and cloth and food with the kind of greedy justice that has fed a thousand rebellions.
The last day, Nolan could not stand. He dropped to his knees and begged.
"Please," he said, "I will beg forgiveness. I will give everything."
"Then give us names," I said, "of who else you paid. Let us know if there is more blood you're hiding."
He trembled and then he began to give names. One by one, small houses that had thought themselves safe were revealed. Some of them crumbled. Some of their heads were not clean.
The crowd watched as those who had trusted ledger silence now had their ledgers open. They saw men who had bought lying find themselves burned on the pyre of their own deeds. They saw daughters who had laughed now serve at the village. They saw houses stripped of their food and forced to feed mourners.
Nolan's face withered. Once he had swaggered with a scholar's pride; now he ate two slices of bread and stars blurred.
On the final day, he fell to his knees in front of the maid's family, his mouth open, his chest heaving.
"Please," he said, "I beg your forgiveness. I will give you silver."
The dead woman's daughter—thin, eyes hollow—stood with a baby on her hip and looked Nolan in the face.
"You must take everything but do not buy our forgiveness," she said. "You must live with what your hands did. Take your money and feed others, but do not spend a coin to make us forget. Let the world know you bought silence."
There was silence. Nolan put his face in his hands and wept like a man newly born into sorrow.
The story circled the city. People who had once dined at Nolan's table now told the tale as a lesson. The proud houses took note that silence had a price.
I walked home with Isla and Dorian that night. Dorian squeezed my hand.
"Did it satisfy you?" he asked.
"No," I said. "Punishment is not salvation."
"But you did it well."
"I only opened the door. People shut too quickly when they are comfortable. They forget to look."
Isla's fingers trembled against mine. "Thank you," she whispered.
"You were brave," I said.
She smiled, small and fierce. "You are the one who throws teacups."
"I throw other things," I said. "And sometimes I carry ledger pages."
We went inside. The kitchen still burned. Someone had set a new pot on, thinking to make peace. The city murmured. The scholars in the halls adjusted themselves.
But the worst had been done: the house that had bought silence had been seen. Their ledger lay open on a market table like a bleeding thing. People who had once been silent now spoke. That was the true punishment.
Weeks later, life resumed its tilt. Dorian and I walked in snowlight and planned. I still dug pits—it's how I live—but now they were smaller and more precise. People who had tried to crush others now counted the cost with each breath. I sent care to the old maid's family, and to Bram's kin where I could. I used ledgers to fund shelter and food.
"You wanted them destroyed," Dorian said one night as we warmed our hands on tea.
"No," I answered. "I wanted them broken enough to know shame. That will keep them from the next ledger."
He looked at me with a softness that had room for both steel and warmth.
"You are dangerous," he said.
"I am necessary," I said.
Later, when the city had calmed, someone asked me if I felt better.
"I don't feel better," I said. "But I feel honest. That is its own kind of warmth."
And in the days that followed, every time I passed the market where Nolan's sign had hung, people would bow their heads a fraction. Not because I told them to, but because they had lived through watching a house buy silence and had seen how ugly it appears.
They had learned that if you buy the right to silence you cannot buy the right to forget.
The End
— Thank you for reading —