Revenge14 min read
My Birthday, the R Hat, and the Jar That Never Lets You Die
ButterPicks17 views
"Happy birthday, Kataleya," my mother said, but her smile never reached her eyes.
"I hope your new job goes well." My father stacked a small box beside the cake.
"Blow it out," my sister whispered, almost too quiet to hear.
I laughed, "I wish I never had to deal with annoying customers again. And I wish that woman who complained about me at work gets the worst year possible."
"That's a strange wish," my brother said without looking up from his book, "but okay."
They sang. I closed my eyes and blew. The clock in the hallway ticked and stopped at 8:00.
The next thing I knew I was opening my eyes to the same orange lamp, the same smell of dinner, the same voice from downstairs calling me to come and eat.
"Was I asleep?" I muttered.
"Don't be silly," my mother answered. "You fell into a daydream."
I ate. We joked. My sister and I made plans to go to the mall tomorrow to teach the woman who complained a lesson. I let myself be carried along on the ordinary night.
When I climbed back into bed, the phone buzzed with a push alert I hadn't finished reading earlier: "WANTED: Skin-Swap Killer—43 victims—last seen in our city." The photo was grainy. The man wore a black hand-knit cap, stitched with a red R.
"Nightmare stuff," I told myself. The clock on my bedside table snapped and stuck at 8:00.
I woke to my throat burning and hands slick with blood.
I couldn't breathe. A shadow moved in the bathroom doorway. A low voice said, "Where do you think you're going?"
My mind scrambled. The R on the cap, the news alert—all of it collided under the lightbulb's hum. I tried to scream, but the sound was caught in my chest as a thin, frantic whisper.
"Please," I thought, "not tonight."
"You're shaking. Sit down." The voice wasn't a stranger's for a fraction of a second. It was my brother's. Then a hand pressed like iron against the back of my neck. Glass broke. Frosted tile and red spray filled my mouth.
I died.
I woke again at eight. My throat still burned with phantom pain. The air smelled of orange lamp and cake frosting. I ran downstairs and told them the whole thing.
"You're scaring me," my mother said, smoothing my hair. "Maybe you need rest."
"I checked every lock," I insisted. "There were footprints."
"You had a nightmare," my sister said, relieved. "Relax."
I didn't relax.
That night, I spent hours tapping every wall, pressing for hollow sounds, looking for seams. The bathroom tiles were cold and smooth. Nothing. Yet later I did find a seam—one evening when I pushed a tile and a dull thunk echoed. A panel slid away to reveal darkness swallowing the floor.
I pried and dug until I tore plaster and exposed a gray cement pocket. Nothing but empty space. I hammered with a small dumbbell until my knuckles bled. My fingertips found a tin box behind a loose brick: old IDs, a child's bracelet, a yellowing newspaper clipping—"Serial Killer Still at Large." And a small black cap with a stitched red R.
My hands went cold as the pieces fit into a terrible map.
"Who would make a copy of our house?" I whispered. "Who would keep a box with my face in it?"
"Is that you under the bed?" my sister asked from the doorway.
"No," I lied. "Go to sleep."
That night I hid in the closet. They slept downstairs like a family portrait, but when I peered from the crack, the smiles had the wrong angles. I watched my mother—Camille Brandt—lean forward and stare at the ceiling, eyes unblinking, and my father, Cedric Henry, lifting his head to look past the light into nothing that seemed to include me.
When I opened the closet, my hand brushed a stack of papers. Death certificates—my name listed, and a date: today.
I shoved them back and crawled behind the curtains. The room burned. I woke with my lungs full of smoke. I clawed a window and tried to climb out. My sister—Antonia Contreras—appeared above me in the dark and pushed. The world turned black.
I woke again at eight, alive, shaking, with burnt hair and the taste of ash at the back of my throat. That time I didn't pretend.
"This isn't a dream," I told them. "Someone is hurting me. There's a secret room. Someone is wearing an R hat."
My brother looked up from his book only once.
"Calm down," he said. "You're tired."
"I found their room," I snapped. "I'm not a child."
He closed the book with a whisper. "I'll check the basement. Tomorrow."
He left the way he always did—sober, precise, unreadable.
When he returned, he didn't speak. He moved like a man with a plan. He checked my cuts as if they were injuries to an experiment subject, not his sister. That night, my sleep was thin and patched by fear. At 11:00 I waited with a screwdriver under my pillow.
A shadow creaked at my door.
He came into the room in silence, a hulking shape masked by a cap with a red R. I lunged. He pinned me to the floor. A thin, clean noise hissed between my ribs.
I stabbed. The world became wet and loud. He fell and crawled into a hole in the wall no one had ever noticed.
I ran. I called for Mom and Dad. I told them. They said nothing. They looked, and their eyes slid past me like water past glass.
Then my sister pushed me over the bannister.
I died again.
I woke up at eight.
By then I knew the pattern: every night something changed, and each time I woke at 8:00 to begin the loop anew. The cake, the family, the R hat, the hidden door—same as before, different death.
I learned to watch. I learned to record. I hid a card inside a bookcase. I learned that when I fell, the house would become B—the other house they dragged me to when I passed out. I learned that a set of footprints led from my bed to a concreted tunnel and that piece by piece, reality folded itself like a trapdoor.
One day behind the seam I finally stepped into the sub-basement for good. A door with flaking red paint groaned open. The crawlspace opened to a room larger than I expected, cluttered but with one corner painstakingly neat. Photos pinned to the wall—thousands of victims. The hat. The IDs. My own face on a dog-eared license.
I was breathing like a person after drowning.
I rifled through the files. I found a blue folder marked with dates, with pictures, with a hat pressed like a relic. I found, among the paper ghosts, the one that should have been impossible: an old photo of a man who had died years ago—the real Lin—for whom a killer had stolen identity. And then a name that made my stomach turn: Callahan Compton.
Not mine at all—Callahan had been my brother all along, but the documents suggested different attachments. My hands trembled when I reached into the wooden box and pulled out a knitted black cap, its fabric hard with old blood, the red R crooked as a smirk.
Footsteps. Voices.
"Do you think she will notice?" someone said.
"She always notices," another voice answered, quieter.
I crouched behind a sofa as two figures—my father and a man I didn't recognize—entered.
"She found the files?" my father asked.
"Probably," the stranger said. "She always snoops. We have to close the loop tonight."
"Don't let her scream," my father said. "Callahan will handle the rest."
A hand pressed on my head, and my body floated. I was being carried. Through the hole of the wall, through the tunnel, then into darkness.
They put me into a room that smelled of antiseptic and old coffee. Monitors blinked. Men in lab coats walked by with practiced indifference. The cap lay in a tray in front of someone hooked to a machine.
I stepped closer. The man's face was a map of wounds—right eye scar, three white slashes across his cheek. He looked up like a trapped animal.
"Who are you?" I whispered.
He smiled like a man forgiven by God. "Callahan," he said—the same name I loved and hated—and it broke my chest. "I'm Callahan," he said, but his voice was not my brother's. It was softer, edged with an old hurt. "Do you want to hear the truth?"
He did not hesitate. He motioned to a recorder.
"I am not your family," he said. "But I want you to know everything."
He told a story that unspooled like a film you cannot unsee.
"I used to be a doctor," Callahan said. "I studied brains. I wanted to cure pain. My sister—Antonia—she fell in love with a man who lied to us. He couldn't be tamed. He destroyed everything. He took my sister. He left me with the smell of blood. I couldn't forget."
"Who was he?" I whispered.
"A man with many faces," Callahan said. "His name now is Vaughn Green. He stole a life and wore it like clothing. He killed thirty, forty-three people in his madness. He thought he would never be found."
"Why are you doing this?" I demanded.
"Because pain is a teacher," Callahan answered. "And some people must learn forever."
"You're telling me you put him in a machine?" I said.
"I put him where his mind cannot hide," Callahan said flatly. "You, me, Antonia—none of that mattered to him. He had to live each wound again and again. He had to feel what he made others feel. I built a device. I called it the Jar."
"You tortured him," I said.
"I made him remember," Callahan said. "And I made him aware that every night he would be made to live and die—trapped in the exact loops he forced on you. Every time he died in there, the world would not move on. He would fall into the same moments until he could see the pattern and, perhaps, break down."
"That's monstrous," I said.
"Maybe," Callahan said. "But you survived. You kept waking at eight. You kept opening the door. You found evidence. You opened the path to B."
He reached for my hand and in that small gesture I recognized my brother—the man inside the story. He looked exhausted and ancient.
"I needed you to keep waking," he whispered. "You are my anchor. I needed to see whether the machine could break someone or whether it—"
"Kill them?" I finished for him.
"Kill only if they were already dead inside," he said.
I didn't forgive him right away.
We argued. We cried. We replayed the places and times. He told me about the lab, about the man in the chair—Vaughn Green—who had been brought alive into the Jar as part of an agreement with authorities: stay alive in the system and volunteer testimony to crimes, you get a trial; or something worse. Callahan altered the terms.
"Where is he now?" I asked.
"Locked in the Jar," Callahan said. "But I couldn't leave it to private revenge. I took a dangerous path. I made a plan. Tonight, the world will see him."
"See him?" I said.
"I will make his punishment public," he said. "Not the Jar rooms—no, that would be cruel without closure. I will bring him to the place where his masks fall. He will be made to answer, in daylight, with evidence, with witnesses. He will be unmasked."
"Publicly?" I repeated.
"Yes," Callahan said. "A press hall. The family of the victims will be there. The cameras will be there. He will stand, and he will hear what he did reflected from the mouths of those he destroyed."
"You think that'll help?" My voice cracked.
"It will make him small," he said. "And small men sometimes reveal more truths when the world is loud."
We planned the reveal. I hated that his revelation felt like both a rescue and a new horror.
The night came.
They wheeled Vaughn into a glass case at the center of a packed auditorium. Flashing lights blinked like false stars. People murmured. The box was not meant as a torture—it was a transparent cage with sound dampeners so that his voice would not carry. He wore no cap now. The red R was absent. His face smelled of someone who had not slept in years.
"You are Vaughn Green?" Callahan asked into the microphone. "You know why you are here?"
Vaughn smiled, thin as a seam. "I know things," he said. "I remember faces."
"You remember them because you took them," Callahan said. "You took Antonia. You took children. You took lives."
A woman at the front row raised her hand, trembling. "My sister," she cried. "He was at my door. He left a mark I can't wash off."
Cameras rolled. A sea of phones pointed at the cage.
"Tell them," Callahan said. "Tell them who else you were."
Vaughn's eyes drifted, slow and hungry. "I wore people," he said. "I learned their smells. I learned how their houses were built. I crawled behind curtains. I made them trust me."
"Why?" someone shouted.
"Because," Vaughn said, "I needed to be a man who could hold a life. I stole them because I could not make one. I thought if I wore enough, someone would stick."
"Is that an apology?" Callahan asked.
"Apology is a word for people who know what they did," Vaughn said. "I know what I did. I know the warm of lungs leaving a throat."
The auditorium shuddered.
"Show them," Callahan ordered. He tapped a nearby screen. Images rolled—photos of victims, the little bracelet, the yellowed IDs. A slow, meticulous catalog of people he had taken.
"That hat," a voice from the crowd said. "I've seen that hat."
"I sewed it," Vaughn said, and the room gasped. "I made it to feel right. Each stitch had a name."
"Do you remember Antonia?" Callahan asked. "Do you remember how she laughed? Do you remember how she called your name at three in the morning?"
Vaughn did not answer.
"Do you remember me?" Callahan said softly. "Do you remember what you took from me?"
Vaughn's mouth tightened. "You were all noise," he whispered. "I wanted silence."
A man stood up in the back, shaking. "What he did—" he started, then stopped, his whole body trembling. He looked at Vaughn like a dog looks at a wolf. "He did this to my sister."
A chorus of voices rose. "Shame!" "Monster!" "How could you?"
Vaughn laughed, an ugly sound that vibrated in the glass. He bared teeth like a dog in a trap.
"Do you want us to forgive you?" Callahan asked him.
"We don't forgive," the mother in front said, voice breaking. "We want him to answer. We want to know why."
Under the lights, Vaughn's expression shifted. For the first time a human feature cracked. His face, which had been a mask of indifference, flickered into alarm.
"You're making me a joke," he said. "You can't—"
"We can," Callahan said. "We gathered the proofs. We laid your history like a map."
Photographers snapped. A mother screamed his name. The lights seemed to push him into the center of himself.
He tried to look stern. He grew small. People in the crowd pushed forward, some shouting, some filming, some crying. A teenage girl stepped up and held a faded doll toward the glass. Vaughn's eyes locked on it, and something like pleading came into his face.
"I didn't mean—" he started, and then the line broke.
"Tell us one thing," Callahan said. "Tell Antonia's mother why."
Vaughn's lips trembled. His breathing stuttered. For a moment, I thought he'd break into a confession soft as sleep. Instead he did the strangest thing: he looked right at me.
"You always wake at eight," he said as if he knew a secret. "I watched you. I waited. I was curious about how long you could scream without waking the house."
The auditorium leaned away as if a smell of rot had swept through. Phones clicked like an insect hive.
"You're going to answer," Callahan said. "I will make sure you answer."
That was the moment the public punishment shifted. Cameras had recorded his smirk. He had been made small, yes, but his eyes were bright with a new terror. He had expected a crowd to feast on him and be satiated. Instead he discovered something worse—the gaze of everyone who had her life torn away.
His composure evaporated. At first he tried to lie. Then he tried to charm. Then he raged. "You don't know me!" he barked. "You don't know what I'll do!"
They laughed. A woman spat toward the glass. Someone recorded the spat and sent it live. Comments in the live feed shrieked. A chorus of contempt rose into the rafters.
"Apologize," someone shouted.
"Say her name," another commanded.
Vaughn leaned into the microphone and said nothing. He swallowed and then, for the first time, his face crumpled as if being unmade. He tried to speak and found only a thin whisper.
"Antonia," he said, and it was not a name but a broken stone.
The mother—she rose up like a tide. She told him what he had done in precise detail. She told him the way they had found her body. She told him he had stolen a laugh no one could replace. She told him she had spent years learning to breathe again.
Vaughn tried to respond. He cried. He screamed. He begged, in a way that resembled theater more than remorse.
The crowd pressed nearer. Cameras flickered. A scandalous roar poured into the hall—phones broadcasting, people filming, others hissing harsh noises. Some were angry; others were relieved. A few shouted for blood.
I watched Vaughn's reactions: first thin smirk, then irritation, then panic, then a child's pleading, then a small animal in a trap. He moved through layers of expression like a man walking through rooms of his life. The faces in the crowd mirrored the wounds he had inflicted—they pulsed, as if his confession gave them permission to open and be seen.
At the end, he collapsed in the glass cube and sobbed so hard he shook its walls.
"It is not enough," I whispered to Callahan.
Callahan's face was tired but certain. "No," he said. "Not enough. But the world knows him now. The world will not forget."
They rolled the cage out into a wider hall where more people could see. The cameras captured every tear, every spasm. The live streams overflowed with comments—some supportive, some cruel. But the important thing was that the mask had been stripped. Vaughn was exposed.
What followed was a legal storm. The evidence—photos, caps, IDs—went to courts and to journalists. Vaughn's trial became a crucible. The prosecution painted him a monster; the defense tried to make him human. He was convicted on multiple counts, and the world watched him shrink under the weight of words. He asked for mercy and didn't get it. He begged for the Jar; he asked to have the loops replayed until he was done.
In the courtroom, the public punished him in ways the Jar never could. They shouted his name. They played the tapes of his laugh. They made him watch relatives describe the years of small, daily grief. He stood exposed and shook until the judge silenced the room.
Outside, as he was taken away, a line of victims' families pressed forward. Cameras recorded the moment the man who had worn people's lives like clothing was forced to look at the ruined faces he had left behind. Photographers trampled the ground between him and the crowd; some people spat near his shoes; others stood and stared like statues.
Vaughn's reaction was a collapse that began with defiance and ended in a kind of crumpled whimpering. "I didn't mean to do all of it," he said. "I didn't know... I couldn't stop."
"How do you limit a man who chose to erase others?" one voice called from the crowd.
He was driven away. The courtroom emptied, but the record remained. After the verdict, I walked home with Callahan and Camille and Cedric in a stiff silence. Justice had been served in one way, but the Jar remained—its moral weight a secret between us.
"Why keep it?" I asked Callahan later. "You already turned him into a public spectacle. Why the Jar as well?"
"Because public punishment reveals what he is," he said. "The Jar lets him understand. The Jar makes him live what he dished out. The two together make a man small—and possibly, if anything could, teach him to see."
I thought about the nights I had relived: how little the world noticed the small deaths. The Jar was ugly and brilliant—a machine that rewired memory, a cage that forced truth. I had woken at eight a hundred times now, and each time I tasted the same bitter frosting.
And yet now, after the public punishment, something shifted. The rest of his life would be paperwork and candles and names. He would see faces and hear names. He would have to bear them. The crowd's roar had been a crucible; the Jar's cruelty was a private hammer.
At home the clock still stuck at eight. The cake had crumbs. The black cap with the red R sat on a shelf in evidence, pressed behind glass in the inspector's office. Nothing would ever look quite the same.
"Will this stop the loop?" I asked Callahan one night, the two of us in an empty lab.
"Maybe," he said. "Maybe when the world knows, the Jar stops needing to replay. Or maybe loops are stubborn as grief. I can't promise."
"You tricked me," I said. "You let me live in a world like B to catch him."
"I couldn't let it go," Callahan said. "You survived. You found the proof. You made the punishment public. That counts for something."
He was right and wrong. The loops continued to come like small waves for a while, but each time the nightmare felt thinner, like an old film stripping. I would wake at eight, and sometimes the house was just a house. Sometimes I woke to silence and a coffee cup on the table, not a camera or a man in a cap.
The world moved on. Vaughn's face was in the papers. The Jar remained locked, a private apparatus humming in a lab beneath our feet. Callahan kept working, checking code and reading EEGs. He slept less. He smiled not at me but at the idea that he had at least tried to make the man see.
"Do you regret it?" I asked him once in the lab while he scrubbed a memory file with his thumb.
"I wanted him to be judged publicly," Callahan said. "And privately, to be forced to know what he did."
"You took a life of revenge," I said.
"I took a life and gave him many deaths," he said flatly.
Months later, in a small, strange closure, Antonia's name was read at a memorial. People held candles. The crowd murmured. Callahan stood stiffly beside me. Camille cried. Cedric gripped my hand until his knuckles went pale.
"She would have laughed at us," Callahan said under his breath.
"She would have laughed at you making such an awful machine," I said.
"Maybe she would have."
In the back, a man in a black suit walked up and placed a folded paper at the memorial. "From a stranger," he mouthed.
It was a photograph from the Jar: Vaughn's face, a fraction of a smile where he could not help but show teeth, caught in one of his infinite replays. It looked like the greatest crime and the worst apology.
The end of the story doesn't tie neatly. I still wake at eight sometimes. The clock in the hallway still bounds five ticks then sticks. But now when it sticks, it reminds me: we can make a man answer, in daylight, with witnesses, with evidence. We can make a world know what he did.
My last memory before sleep these days is the knitted cap on the evidence shelf—the crooked red R—and the hum from below where the Jar waits like a slow, moral machine.
"Will you turn off the Jar?" I ask Callahan at night.
He looks at the machine and says, "Not yet. Some machines are built for truth, not comfort."
I put my hand near the cap in the evidence room one last time, feeling the dried threads under my fingers. I don't know if the Jar redeemed him or consumed him. But I know this: a man who kept wearing other people's faces no longer wears them in front of the world.
And tonight, for the first time in a year, the clock passed eight without stopping.
The End
— Thank you for reading —