Sweet Romance10 min read
The Bell, the Cat, and the Night He Chose Her
ButterPicks11 views
I never expected a tipped trash bin to change everything.
"I'll pick that up," my voice was small. "Sorry, I—"
"You okay?" my mother asked on the phone. "By the way, Alyssa's back."
I froze mid-wipe. The rag in my hand seemed to fall heavier. Through the crack of the door I saw Boris on the sofa, half-turned, playing with Dumpling, the ragdoll cat we'd both coddled. He looked calm, like water without waves. I hit end.
"She came back already?" I whispered.
"Didn't you know?" my mother said. "Her fiancé cheated. She's back to... clear her head."
My fingers tightened. I could hear Boris's laugh faintly from the living room. The sound should have been ordinary. It wasn't.
"You didn't tell me—" I started, then cut it off. I stepped closer to the door. Boris moved his hand along Dumpling's spine with a careful motion. "Emery, wait," he said, not looking up. "Can you—just wait a bit?"
My heart stuttered. I remember when I first gave Dumpling to Boris half a year ago. He'd accepted the little bundle, named it "Dumpling," and said, "It's soft, like you." He had smiled then—just once—warm and small. That smile had been my map. I had followed it and gotten lost.
The trash bin tipped when Dumpling stampeded past my feet. A condom box slid out and a soft roll of something sticky, half-wrapped in tissue, tumbled beside it. I moved in a haze and shoved everything back, as if secrecy could reverse what my ears had already gathered.
"By the way, your aunt said Alyssa flew in last night," my mother said. "She didn't call you?"
I was a cognitive blur. The phone hit the hardwood like a stone. I realized, all at once, that last night I had called Boris a dozen times. No answer. Last night I had sat in a dark cinema waiting for him. He'd promised he'd buy tickets. He'd texted "I'll get them." He didn't. He'd gone to her.
"Emery?" my mother kept talking. "She might stay at his place a few days. Poor girl. She needs a place."
I closed my eyes. The sound of Boris saying "Alyssa..." in that warm cadence I had never heard for me, hit like ice.
I walked out. Boris turned, saw me at the doorway, and in a voice that hadn't prepared me for coldness said, "I have some things to do. Emery, you should go."
My chest shrank. "Why are you telling me to leave your own apartment?" I asked, though I knew the answer.
Alyssa arrived just then, dripping with jet-lag and something like contrition. She hugged Boris awkwardly, and then, when she laughed at a story he told, her face lit with a softness I had once mistaken for hers alone.
"Thank you for letting me crash," she said to him. Her voice was gentle, public.
He took her hand like she'd left it an imprint. "You're allergic to cat hair, I remember. Don't worry about Dumpling—I'll take care of him." He said it so tenderly my lungs seized.
I left with Dumpling's bag in my arms, because my hands were shaking too much to remember anything else. I set a small bell—our bell—on the hall table before I left, then, halfway out the door, looked back and left the spare key on the console. It felt like spilling the last grain of hope.
"You're not a priority," I told myself later as I fed Dumpling. "You never were."
That night, a fever swallowed me. I don't remember much, only waking in a quiet bedroom to the smell of seafood porridge.
"You're awake," Thierry said. He stood in the doorway with a bowl and a patient smile. "You ran a fever. I made you something."
Thierry Johansen had come back to town, he'd said at dinner: "I've been asked to take a temporary project here." The first night I met him properly, he was like warm cement—steady, polite, but there was something under the surface. He pulled the blanket higher over my shoulders as if making room for me in his life. "You should stay," he told me then.
"Thierry?" I said now, surprised to see him. "Did Boris—"
"No," he said simply. "He left you some things. He said you'd come collect them."
He didn't ask for boasts. He didn't ask for reasons. He cooked, he waited, he asked about my favorite condiments—"You don't like scallions, right?"—and when I said nothing he smiled as if I was an answer he'd been knitting.
I slept. When I woke, messages piled: Alyssa's "I'm so sorry", my mother's worried voice notes, strangers from work checking in. One line wasn't there: Boris.
A few days became a pattern. Boris would be distant or present in small careful ways. When he was present, he was sharp and protective toward Alyssa. When he was with me he was dutiful and polite. Once, in a crowded dinner with a friend, his hand found mine beneath the table and held—like a claim. I felt a charge, then a dull flame of embarrassment when I realized he'd done it because our friend asked the waiter to remove the scallions. He knew. He'd known before and didn't tell me. I bit my tongue.
Thierry arrived in my life with small things: an extra knit, a message in the morning, a ride home when it rained. He didn't wave a flag and he didn't demand my explanation. He simply mutated the shape of the days into something livable.
"You can't keep living in someone else's shadow," he said once, pouring tea.
"Who are you to tell me that?" I snapped, half-joking, half-wounded.
"Someone who wants to help you stop limping," he answered.
Our closeness was quiet. He pulled my chair in, heated my towel, fixed the crooked shelf I had never told anyone about. He remembered the smallest details: how I tap the corner of a cup when I'm thinking, how I hate waking to dark. He wasn't a grand rush of passion. He was a slow heat that grew in the chest until it warmed everything around me.
Boris, predictably, noticed. He'd come by late once, his shirt clinging with rain, eyes wild. "You can't just—" he started.
"I'm here," I said, firm. "Thierry's been here. He's cooked for me and made me feel safe."
"Boris, you look terrible," Alyssa said when she came to check on him. "You should—"
He flinched. I saw that edge in him again: the confusion when someone else cared for him differently. It was like sunlight catching him and showing rust.
One night, Thierry took me to a bungee jump. "Trust me," he said.
"You actually think I can jump?" I laughed.
"Yes," he said, in that flat tone he used when he chose the words carefully. "You can."
I jumped and everything that had been heavy inside me fell like the plummet. After, Thierry squeezed my hand like a promise.
We were changing. I felt it in the small things: how I looked at my phone, what I packed for dinner, how I imagined a weekend.
Then came the night of the punishment.
Boris had always been the sort of man to believe the world was a quiet room where you could rearrange furniture without anyone noticing. He presumed loyalties were private and faces were for intimate spaces. That smug security blindsided him.
A local friend was hosting a rooftop birthday for a common acquaintance. It was the sort of event where old classmates gathered and photos were snapped, the kind of night where reputations are visible in glass and laughter. Alyssa came as if to disappear into the crowd. Boris arrived in a suit that fit too well and a smile rehearsed. Thierry and I had debated whether we should go. In truth, the decision was simple: I wanted to see how he moved among people who had seen him before me.
The party had the city's lights all around like a bright backdrop. I stood at the edge, Dumpling's small bell in my palm. Thierry, careful as always, stood beside me. We made ourselves small. Then Alyssa moved toward the DJ, clutching her clutch like a paper boat. Boris was at the bar, laughing with someone. He looked relaxed.
"Do you want to leave?" Thierry asked softly.
"No," I replied. "I don't."
I walked up with Thierry. "Hi," I said, voice even.
"Emery!" a mutual friend called. "Come join us!"
Conversations bubbled. A few minutes passed like floating notes. Then I asked a question that had been simmering in my throat for months.
"Boris," I said, loud enough for the group to hear, "why did you leave me in a movie theatre?"
There was a small, almost polite silence. Someone laughed, awkward. Boris's face shifted. He opened his mouth, closed it. "I—Emery, that was—"
"Was what?" I asked. "An oversight? A preference? Or did you prefer to go home to Alyssa?"
People glanced, eyes shifting like water. I saw the little cracks forming in Boris's composure. He stepped forward as if to take my hand and explain. I didn't offer it.
"Do you want to tell everyone here how you told me you'd wait?" I asked. "Do you want to tell them how you told Alyssa you'd take her in? Do you want them to hear the voice messages you left me—or didn't leave?"
Boris's mouth went dry. His laugh failed. People started to look more, leaning forward, the way an audience does when a play hits the crux. I had a pocketful of things: text logs, screen shots, and—someone I'd confided in—had handed over a recording. Thierry stood to the side, face an iron calm.
"Emery, this isn't necessary—" Boris started, voice low.
"Necessary for what?" I looked at Alyssa, who stood pale, and then at Boris. "To keep pretending I was the only one?"
Alyssa's face crumpled. "Emery, I—"
"Let her speak," someone said.
She swallowed and placed a trembling hand on the microphone the DJ had handed her. "I was hurt," she said. "But no one knows the whole story. He cried to me, he told me he couldn't lose me—" she hesitated, and then the confession came like a door opening. "He made choices. He asked me to stay. He..."
She trailed off. Eyes around us brightened with gossip-starved hunger. Someone shouted, "Tell us what he said!" Another asked, "Did he cheat?"
I stepped forward and set my phone on the small table where the DJ had his console. "Play this," I said.
Thierry's hand was steady on my back. The DJ glanced at us, bemused, and pressed play.
Boris's voice, recorded from a night months earlier, filled the rooftop: muttered apologies to Alyssa rehearsed in the dark. Another clip—his message to me from the night of the movie, "Can't make it, Emery. Sorry, not well," delivered with a casualness I'd memorized. The guests listened as the growling contrast played: the warm, fussy care in his words for Alyssa and the clipped, indifferent offers to me.
Boris's face went through the stages I'd read about in books: first disbelief, then flush, then a quick strain of denial. "That's not—" he began.
"Isn't what?" I asked. "Isn't the truth?"
He stammered, "You shouldn't have—this is private."
"Private?" someone scoffed. "You're a public person in our circle, and you treat people like props."
A small chorus of whispers rose, then a hush. People lined up to speak. One by one they recited small slights: the times Boris stood someone up, the coolness he'd displayed to others he used to be kind to, the favors he expected and never reciprocated. A woman I barely knew told of a dinner where he'd insulted a friend then smiled as if nothing had happened.
Boris's changing expressions were a study: from numb surprise to sharp anger ("You set me up!"), to beseeching ("Emery, please, I'm sorry"), to fraying shame as supportive hands turned away. He called my name, voice cracking, "Emery, you don't understand—"
"I do," I said quietly. "I understand enough."
Cameras on phones bloomed. People recorded. Faces that had once admired him now watched with the rapt attention that comes when someone who appeared unblemished reveals scars. There was confusion, then shards of betrayal. A few guests murmured, "We always thought he was cold—look at that." Some pushed for details. A few took pictures and posted them, as if to seal the verdict.
Boris grabbed for me then, as if he could physically pull me back into the place he wanted to have me. "Please," he said, voice raw. "Don't humiliate me."
I looked out at the city lights, then at Thierry, who stood like a lighthouse beside me. My hands held the bell. Dumpling's bell. I had no appetite for cruelty, only for the truth to be seen.
"You made your bed," I said. "You chose what to give and to whom. You can ask for forgiveness, but you can't ask me to be your secret and your convenience."
He fell silent. The crowd's reaction shifted from sensational gossip to bitter realization. Some turned away; some whispered in pity; one neighbor I recognized from the building leaned forward and said, "I used to think you were trustworthy."
"You're hurting people," someone else said.
He sank into a bench, breath coming in ragged lines. "I didn't mean—" He looked at Alyssa. "I thought I was helping you..."
Alyssa's voice was small. "You helped me. You hurt Emery."
There was no dramatic collapse, no violent exchange of blows. The punishment was the slow, public unmasking—friends choosing sides, the shaming in the lights, the documentation on phones that would live on. For him, each camera was a small needle, and the room's shifting gaze cut. He shifted from denials to pleas as the audience's faces crystallized from a soft fondness to sober judgment.
Finally, he left the rooftop alone. He stepped into the night with his jacket pulled up, a man whose house of carefully placed favors had a crack now visible to anyone who cared to look. People murmured behind him. They would talk about it for weeks. They would treat him differently. He would go to parties and find his name whispered rather than toasted. He would, in ways both big and petty, lose the comfort of presumption.
I stood with Thierry, hands clasped. He squeezed then, not triumphantly, but with the small quiet of someone who had witnessed me take back a part of myself. The bell in my pocket jingled faintly.
"Was that necessary?" he asked softly.
"Yes," I said. "It was."
The next weeks washed in new patterns. Boris occasionally tried to reach out—text messages, one awkward voicemail. I listened to one of his apologies once: it was full of regret and excuses. I heard it and placed it in a folder labeled "Lessons." He asked to see me once, at a coffee shop, cheeks hollow. I said no.
Thierry, steady and kind, asked for nothing. He only gave: his time, small favors, a present for Dumpling. He showed up when I moved (again) and insisted on carrying more than his share of boxes. He asked, once, when the moving guy pushed a stack of boxes: "Are you happy?" I answered, "Yes," because with him, happiness felt like a plain surface I could set a cup on.
Months later, I found myself laughing at an inside joke Thierry and I had. I found myself sleeping without waking to check my phone. I found Dumpling curled on my lap, the bell hanging silent but there, a small constant.
Boris's fall wasn't dramatic on paper—it was the loss of the private comforts he'd assumed; the way people stopped giving him the benefit of the doubt. He was not arrested, not publicly shamed by law, but what mattered to him—appearance, convenience, the unthinking generosity of acquaintances—froze and fractured. He found doors that used to open for him closed, watched as acquaintances who once smiled when he entered now looked past him. When he attempted to fortify himself in familiar haunts, friends who had once laughed with him now greeted him with a diplomatic distance. He learned, in the quiet and the small humiliations, that charm works only if others permit it.
Thierry never gloated. He sat with me in long silences and taught me that being held is not the same as being owned. He baked bad bread and we ate it and laughed. He bought me a small notebook and wrote the first line, "Emery, for small things and for big ones." Inside, he drew a tiny bell. "So you keep it," he said.
When I finally closed my phone one evening and deleted a thread of messages from Boris, I felt nothing like triumph. I felt relieved. Dumpling nudged my hand and pawed at the bell. I shook it and it made a sound bright and small.
"Keep it somewhere safe," Thierry said, resting his chin on my head.
I put the bell in the drawer of the nightstand—on the right, under a stack of unworn envelopes. It was mine now: a tiny, jingling proof that I had been brave enough to speak.
The End
— Thank you for reading —