Revenge12 min read
The Magnolia Earrings — A Court of Masks and Reckoning
ButterPicks12 views
I remember the first time I saw the magnolia earrings glinting in the dim room of the Duke's house. They were small, carved in pale stone, as if someone had trapped morning in a pair of buds. "Keep them," the Duke said, and the world tilted.
"You must look after them like you would look after a secret," he added, as if the words were the same thing.
"I will," I answered, and I meant it from the moment my palms closed around the cool stone.
"You're sure you won't be frightened of the city?" he asked once, when the carriage was ready.
"I was afraid once." I tilted my head, the way he had taught me to show humility. "Not anymore."
He smiled and patted my hand. "Good. We'll both get what we want."
"Father," I said. "Father, thank you."
He laughed then, a sound like armor clinking. "Thank me when you wear a crown."
"You joke," I said, and we both knew he did not.
"Do not be foolish," he said, lowering his voice. "Be useful."
From the beginning, I understood my place. I was Flavian Dawson's ward—the child he had pulled from a ruin and sewn into his life with a story. I was the foundling with a clean face and a history that could be folded away. I learned to read, to stitch, to ride, to listen. I learned how family names were used like chess pieces.
"Do you know why I brought you here?" he asked once while we practiced archery.
"You wanted someone to make you proud?" I tried on the answer like a glove.
He cocked his head. "Pride is flattering. Power is safer."
"Then make me useful," I said. "Teach me how to be the thing you need."
He did. He taught me how to be the daughter he could show when he wanted loyalty to shine. He taught me how to be patient. He taught me how to wait.
"Do you think you could ever love a prince?" he asked one night, the fire throwing hard light on his carved face.
"I could do whatever you need," I said, and it was close enough.
When the prince—Chase Dietrich—first looked at me in the garden at spring banquet, he studied me as if I were a landscape he had never seen before.
"Do you know a girl from the Earl's house, Valentina?" he asked, not quite looking at me.
I shook my head, an honest motion. "No, sir. I do not."
He searched my face with slow fingers. "You look like her. There is a mark between her brows shaped like a lotus."
"I have no mark," I said. "But I like the lotus."
He laughed at that and supplied me with food, with attention, with questions that cut to the inside.
"You prefer chestnuts out of the stew?" he asked later at table, sliding a spoon toward me.
I looked at him, feigning surprise. "I prefer them whole, not smashed. It keeps the taste."
He blinked as if I'd spoken a foreign language. "Even your food matches her."
"I don't know her," I said. "But perhaps it's a good fate."
"Fate," he said, and the word was a small confession. "Maybe it is."
Valentina Sanchez existed in a gilded house at the edge of my knowledge; she was the real shape of the prince's devotion. That fact made me a tool, at first. Flavian had paid handsomely to know Valentina's habits, her favorite dishes, the tilt of her smile. I learned what he fed her, what she read, what made her lower her eyes.
"You're very clever," he told me the night I wore the magnolia earrings to the ball. "You are exactly like her."
I bowed. "Thank you. I only do what I am asked."
He smoothed my sleeve in a motion that belonged to him alone. "You do more than you think."
The city liked the story of two women who looked like one another. It loved the scandal of resemblance. People whispered that I was trying to be Valentina. People whispered that Valentina was the original, and I the copy. Flavian did not mind the gossip. He liked the pictures the city made.
"Let them whisper," he said. "We will win anyway."
Valentina was proud, cold in the way that made men unsteady. She accepted the prince's gifts and made them vanish like mist. At a great lady's dinner she tossed the magnolia earrings of the prince aside as if the gesture were meant to sting me and not to show the prince she could dictate the rhythm of the room.
"You did not need them," she said to me, voice like silk on ice. "You make me want to keep what I choose."
"I do not keep what is given," I said, and left her to her triumph.
Gossip turned to strategy turned to ceremony. I was trained to be the decorous daughter of a great house. I learned to make dishes that soothed, to answer the emperor's questions with the right bow.
"Would you abandon everything to be with the prince?" the Emperor—Garrett Fields—asked me in the great hall with the sun striking his rings.
"Yes," I said. "I would."
"Then it's done," he said aloud, and the sound of the word settled into my bones.
Valentina could not stand the possibility that the prince might move on. She tried to reclaim him with theater and tears, with public apologies and private schemes. She invited me to the frozen lake and smiled like a careful animal.
"Trust me," she said, and the ice creaked.
When I slipped and the great sheet of ice broke, I went down into water so cold it seemed to take the breath from my future. I could have given up. I could have played the victim forever. Instead, I made a plan in shivering clarity.
"Chase!" I cried when he arrived, and he came with a man's fury that had been kept bottled for too long.
He steadied me and he carried me back. "Why would you go near thin ice?" he demanded, half tender, half wild.
Valentina's face was a white mask. "I was only playing," she said.
"She fell," I told him, "because she wanted you to see she could."
Chase looked at me—really looked—and something cracked open.
Later, when the selection rolls were read and the palace brimmed with expectant women, the Emperor asked questions meant to find measure and mind. I answered with caution, with the practiced honesty of a girl made by someone else's hands.
"Will you lay down everything?" the Emperor asked again, and I said "Yes" like a vow.
Valentina tried to bait me in the hall. "You knew what you were doing," she hissed. "You meant to take my place."
"Did I?" I asked simply. "Did you want the prince to spend his life ensuring you did not need him?"
"You can't take what is mine." Her eyes flashed like knives.
"I do not want what is yours." I turned, climbing the carriage steps. "This position belongs to her, not to me."
"Then leave," she spat. "Go."
I pressed my skirts and smiled. "I'm afraid that position has already gone."
The selection day was a clean thing. The Emperor watched, the Empress—Aurora Howell—sat calm and cool, like a pond that hides its depth. Valentina spoke of the prince as if offering a prayer; she tried to make the court believe she was wronged by my being there.
"You sound foolish," the Emperor said, and the court frowned. The prince did not rescue her—he had seen too much. The white moon in his sky began to dim.
She left the hall supported by attendants, cheeks wet with the shame that is heavier than any cloak. I stood and bowed and the Empress smiled once and the court named me what I had been taught to be: the prince's chosen.
The years that followed were a careful construction. Flavian played the humble lord who fed the kingdom while remaining loyal; he bowed in public and clutched his plans close. I bowed and smiled and said, "Thank you," while slowly placing the matches that would set his ruin alight.
"Do not move without me," I told Chase when I found the first of the letters he'd need to know, a scrawled plan in Flavian's hand about planting discord, about slow poisons, about building a private army to "secure the realm." I gave him the letters as if I was handing over a trifle.
"How could you?" he whispered, and I met his eyes with the steady look I had learned from long practice.
"Because I promised you," I said. "And because it is the only way to make what was done to my family mean something."
He did not pull me away. He held my hand and read until morning. His face hardened to stone. "This will not go unpunished," he said.
We waited until the day Flavian walked into the hall thinking his masks still fit. We planned with the Emperor and the Empress and with a small band who owed loyalty to law rather than to terror. We assembled witnesses, we gathered the names of the villages whose cries had been bought and buried. We had proof of the money that had been siphoned, of letters that ordered troops to be elsewhere when the people needed them.
The punishment we gave him was not death at once. We chose spectacle because spectacle makes lessons last. The court would not forget, and neither would the soldiers whose homes had been sold.
The day they brought him out, he was tidy enough to look like the man who had once been feared. He walked with a strut he had never earned, his hands cuffed in front as if he had been used to parading himself in chains and praised for it. He thought he could charm the crowd still.
"You will tell the truth," the Emperor said coldly as the hall filled. "Tell it clearly."
Flavian's jaw worked. "I served my country," he said, loud enough to be heard. "I have done nothing but let my family prosper."
"You let men die," I said. My voice did not shake. "You let children go hungry."
He spat at me. "You little wench. You would turn your father's name against him."
"Father," I said, the word an instrument now. "You built yourself a story and then fed lives to it. You sold grain that could have been sent to the valley and used the gold to line your banquets. You told your soldiers their families were safe while you buried the truth for your own glory."
A murmur swept the hall. Flavian's face, used to giving orders, slackened. For the first time, command did not hold. He laughed at us, uncovered his teeth. "You think you have me? You think the Emperor believes this?"
"Do you deny ordering Captain Mendes to abandon the garrison at River Bend?" Chase demanded, and a captain stepped forward, eyes like flint.
"I denied nothing," Flavian said at first. Then he stopped, as if searching for a new script. His hands went to where his chest would have been had his vanity not hollowed it out. "I did what a lord must."
"You did what would make you king," the Emperor said. "You sold loyalty to buy troops. You thought you could force the line of succession."
A woman in the back, one of the farmers' widows whose yard had been swept away, shrieked. "My boy! My boy was taken when the river broke! He was nine. I have a stone with his name now. And the money for relief—did you buy him a helmet with that? Did you sit while my boy drowned among the logs?"
The hall filled with accusation. Men who had bowed to him now spat and pointed. A young soldier—his uniform fresh with tears—screamed, "You took their bread and offered them rust! You took our names and turned them to dust!"
Flavian's face drained color. He took a breath. "I did what had to be done for my line." The old rhythm of entitlement was there, for a heartbeat. Then it faltered.
"Admit that you diverted the relief fund," I said, stepping closer so that everyone could see my face. "Admit you ordered the troops to march elsewhere when they were needed most. Admit you sold their names for your coins."
He looked at me with something like hatred that had the shape of panic. "You lie. You poison minds with words."
"Do I?" I asked. "Or do the names speak for themselves?"
River Caldwell, who had been in the Duke's service and who had kept ledgers, told the court of accounts, produced receipts, tallied the coins. Andres Bertrand, the soldier's officer, recited orders that had never been justified. Ivory Rocha, who had once been Flavian's housekeeper, turned and named the hidden tomb where his ledgers lay.
The change in Flavian's expression was a map. At first he was disdainful, then shocked, then enraged, then utterly unmoored. His mouth trembled. He began to shout, to call men traitors, to order someone to "stop this farce." As the hall closed in, his voice thinned.
"You're tearing a family down," he howled. "You cannot feed a kingdom with slaughtered men."
"You fed yourself," I said. "You fed your bellies. You took what people needed for your parades."
An officer in the front row, a soldier whose hand had been black with grief, stood and spat into Flavian's shoes. "You wore their corpses like medals," he said. "Now wear their shame."
Gasps and then a low, rising sound filled the hall—jeers, cries, the clacking of sandals. People who had once been too afraid to speak now cried out. Women stepped forward with objects: a child's shoe, a scrap of a tunic, a blackened bowl.
Flavian's face split into a thousand small truths. He tried to laugh but it sounded like a cough. "You will not—" he began.
"We will," the Emperor said. "You will be stripped of title and riches. You will be paraded to the gates. You will be given time to speak your remorse openly, each day in the market where you bought the grain you hid. You will repay what you can. You will bow and beg public forgiveness before every town you misled, until they decide what remains of you."
The sentence was not a death blow; it was worse for him because it made him visible. He had curated every rumor; now he was exposed. The crowd loved the clarity of his fall. It is easier to burn a mask than it is to unmake a man, and yet we insisted he unmask himself in public.
He staggered beneath the verdict. "Emperor," he said, pliant for a moment. "I served—"
"Pray to the families," the Emperor cut him off. "Speak plainly."
Thus began days of spectacle no theater could match. Flavian was led to river towns, to the ruined village on the hillside, to the market where a baby had been held in a blanket soaked in salt water. He knelt in mud, hands bound, and spoke apologies that had the sound of someone reading a script.
He began with silence—pride does not give up easy—and then moved through stages. The first stage was denial; he snarled, he denied the ledger, he blamed clerks. People laughed and spat. The second stage was bargaining: he promised gold he did not have, titles he no longer could give. He promised his empty name. The third stage was anger: he cursed us, called me "unnatural," accused the Emperor of playing king. By the time he reached the fourth stage—sorrow—no one believed him and yet pity touched some faces. Then, finally, he collapsed into a kind of brokenness I had seen in the photos of wrecked houses: a man who had spent his life building facades and found all his props taken away.
Children crowded at his knees, pointing, then weeping because their mothers had scarred faces from the flood. Old women spat and turned away. Young men poured vinegar over the symbolic table where he'd once eaten with the emperor's emissaries and declared he'd done nothing of evil.
"Shame him," they said at first. "Make him feel what we felt." So we did.
On the day his confessions were scheduled in the market, the stall-keepers unclipped their awnings and the city gathered. The Emperor made him answer publicly. Merchants who had been bribed to keep silent gave testimony. Soldiers who had followed him told of being ordered to leave the valley empty. The crowd recorded every word by memory, and some by crude etchings on wood. Banners displayed the names of flooded villages. Flavian's face went from hot to gray to a sallow, leaking look.
At one point a woman held up a child's rattle and asked, "Is this your work?" He could not answer. He covered his mouth and shook as if fevered.
"You see," I whispered to Chase, who stood beside me, "this is the best kind of justice. It is the slow realization."
He squeezed my hand. "You did what you promised."
"I did," I admitted. "And yet—" My stomach clenched. "I wanted him to be the man he pretended to be. He never was."
When at last they carried him back into a small cell with nothing but a straw pallet and a bucket, he had no voice left but hoarse fragments. He called my name once, not with tenderness but with something that might have been accusation.
"You are my daughter," he croaked. "You took this from me."
"I took back what you stole," I said, and then I turned my face away.
The city would retell the scenes for a generation. They would show children the market plaques and tell them how the man who thought he could use human lives as coin was made to count what he had ruined. People cheered. People cried. People remembered.
Afterwards, the court's machinery made sure the army lines were rebalanced, that compensation went to those who had lost crops, that soldiers received honorable pardons, that keys were handed over and mines were inspected.
Chase and I were left with the slow work of stitching the seams of what we'd torn. There were letters of apology, of restitution, of quiet reparations. I moved through rooms with the magnolia earrings always near my ear, and sometimes I would touch them and feel the hard lesson of patience and of the hunger that had fed my revenge.
"Do you regret it?" he asked me one late night when the candles were low and the empty palace smelled of lemon and old paper.
"Sometimes," I admitted. "There are moments I wonder if the price was my heart still more than his head."
He smiled and placed a hand over mine. "You did not act like the woman you were supposed to be. You acted like the woman you chose to become."
"I chose wrong at times," I said. "But I also chose to stop being a tool."
Years later, when our son was born and the midwife placed him into my arms, there was an honest peace that had nothing to do with triumph. Chase laughed and kissed my hair.
"What shall we call him?" he asked.
I looked down at the tiny sure mouth that had already learned how to fuss and to grab. "Call him 'the Little One,'" I said softly, because names are promises and promises must be careful.
Chase laughed and called him "Little Order," half a joke, half a hope. We did not know the shape of his life. We only knew we would try to keep him from learning the taste of being used.
Sometimes, when the palace is quiet and the magnolia tree drops its pale petals, I take out the earrings and hang them above the small cot. The stone buds catch the sunlight and the baby's thumb finds them in early sleep. I watch that thumb close and open, an honest motion, and I remember how long I learned to be precise.
"Remember," I whisper sometimes, to the child, to myself, to the quiet air, "you are not to be traded."
The magnolia earrings swing in the light like a promise.
The End
— Thank you for reading —