Substitute14 min read
The Red Thread and the Secret Garden
ButterPicks21 views
“I’m not dead,” I croaked, tasting blood and dust.
“Good,” a woman’s voice said outside. “If she’s dead, we’re done with risk.”
“Good? Don’t say that like it’s a blessing,” another voice sneered.
I forced my eyes open. Cold wind hit my face. My head felt split. I touched my temple and pulled my hand back bloody.
“What happened? I was making dinner—” I muttered, then heard the two women walk away. Their voices faded.
I blinked. A low stone wall. A torn paper window. A broken door with a gap. The yard had three shabby rooms and nothing else.
“Where am I?” I said. My voice sounded thin.
A memory I didn’t live rolled through me like a cheap movie. I knew this body. I knew its family. My name—well, the body’s name—was Mia Lewis, the fourth daughter of Miles Kelly, Lord of the Kelly Estate. My mother had died when I was born. My father remarried Karen Dumont. My grandmother Joan Burton hated me. Everyone called the old girl generous when they bowed, but she never hid her dislike for my mother’s side.
I clutched my head. “So I’m in her body. Right.” I forced a laugh that turned into a cough.
I tried to stand and the pain flared. I put my hand to the wound and felt sticky heat. Then something odd happened. The blood on my wrist, where I’d wiped it moments before, faded. It blurred, then vanished.
“That’s impossible,” I said. I tested again. The same. The skin cleared like mist.
Curious and a little afraid, I rolled my sleeve up. A thin red cord curled at my wrist. A tiny silver lock sat on it, bright even in the dirt. I whispered, “What are you?”
I pressed the lock the way a child might poke a toy. The world tipped.
One breath, and I stood in another place. Green. Clean. A small field of vegetables. Corn, peaches, herbs—rows of them. Chickens and ducks pecked near a bamboo hut. Inside the hut the shelves held dried roots and neat stacks of books. A back door opened on a sea of flowers with butterflies.
I laughed. It came out shaky and stunned. “A garden?”
The little hut smelled like mint and warm wood. A bowl of peaches sat on the table. I ate one, juice dripping down my chin. The fruit was perfect.
I tugged my wrist. The cord was still there. I untied it, and the yard blinked back into the rotten courtyard.
“This is my private miracle,” I said, so loud that my voice startled me. “Not telling anyone.”
I tied the cord back. The garden returned like it had been waiting. I spent the next hour testing it—going in, coming out. Each visit fixed a cut, made skin smooth. The air inside the garden felt...alive. Like clean sleep.
When the sun dropped, three figures came into the courtyard. A red-garbed lady—my stepmother, Karen—followed by a pale young lady and two older women. They entered like they owned the place.
“Is she gone?” Karen asked, cold as water.
“Mother said she looked dead. She’s still warm, but—” one of the old maids lied.
I lay unnaturally still. The older woman looked down at me with a face that meant business.
“She’s breathing,” Karen said, and stepped closer.
The old maid dropped to her knees. “We will report she’s better. We will say your ladyship found her.”
I heard every move. I wanted to scream, but I breathed and made a small, false whimper.
Karen touched my face, and her pity was a play. “Poor thing,” she said loudly. “You scared us all.”
I opened one eye. “You let me stay here to die,” I said, voice low.
Karen stiffened. “That’s a lie. I have been most concerned.”
The young lady—the oldest girl, Veronica Carter—flitted forward with syrup in her voice. “Mother, we should be kind. She is weak.”
I wanted to laugh. Veronica’s praise floated like cotton. “You always act kind.”
I twisted my hand in the straw, trying to look smaller, harmless. My stomach growled, the sound too loud.
“You are hungry?” Karen asked, with a spice of false tenderness.
“Hungry,” I said, and the lie fit like a glove. The servants shooed me inside and pulled the blanket over me in a public show. They wanted the court to see their kindness.
After they left, the two maids slept like pigs. I pretended to sleep. My plan was simple: recover, keep the garden secret, and leave if I could. I would not be the old body’s pawn.
The next night I crawled to the window and watched. The fat maid Nicole Bolton ate and bragged in the yard.
“You eat and rub it in,” I whispered. “You’ll choke on it.”
Nicole laughed loud. “You hear that? She asks for food like a pig!” She dunked into a bun and smacked.
I waited. When the heavy breathing came, I slipped out of bed and untied the red cord. The garden materialized, and I walked inside, barefoot, tasting peach and fresh earth. I cooked corn and eggs from the space and ate until my hunger bowed down. My body mended. I ran my fingers over old bruises, and they leveled into smooth skin like they had never been.
After two weeks, I felt real again. I could stand all night. I moved with the quiet hush of someone who had learned to hide. I made the garden my secret workshop. I planted and moved roots and seeds. I learned names of herbs from a stack of medicine books found in the hut. I turned the garden into profit in my head. One day the cord would bring money. One day I would buy my freedom.
Then fate knocked.
“Miss Mia? They say the matriarch calls you,” came the maid Haven Estrada’s soft voice. Haven had true eyes. I felt I could trust her. She hugged like rain. I told myself to be careful.
“Go,” I said. “I’ll be fine.”
The matriarch, Joan Burton, sat in a walled garden fit for a small palace, and the other women clustered under her like birds. Her ringed fingers tightened on a fan.
“Mia,” she said without warmth, “we heard you recovered.”
“Yes, grandmother,” I said. I bowed, because the world expected bows.
“Your people say you behaved badly. You must show proper manners before our cousin, Duchess Catalina Henry. She invites our family to her Mid-Autumn banquet at the palace. You will attend.”
People breathed. This was not just an invitation. It was a show. “You are asking me?” I said.
“Duchess Henry asked. I said yes,” Joan replied.
My heart dropped and jumped together. The Duchess was the errant, favored aunt. She was close to the crown. If she touched my life, it could change everything.
“That is good,” Karen said, sick with a false smile. Veronica looked like a student who had skipped to the front of the class.
I wanted to say no. To lock the cord, run into the garden, and never come back. But the palace was a risk and an opportunity. I chose opportunity.
I worked on my shoes. The seamstress measured me. I let my voice practice softness and quiet manners. I smiled when ordered. When the carriage came, I sat in the back and breathed the air like I was smoking a different life.
At the palace gate, banners rippled. People lined the road. The city smelled of glaze and spice. I wanted to run and live on bread and bird song. Instead, we bowed and entered the palace where the light itself seemed to wear gold.
The Duke of the court—Valentino Werner—rode in like a storm. I’d seen pictures of him in the papers. Everyone called him a prince of war and beauty. He had that look that made strangers catch their breath.
“Is that him?” Veronica whispered, smiling a small human smile.
“Keep your hands to yourself,” I told her. “You will trip.”
We sat low against the wall. The Duchess presided like a queen of a smaller court and smiled like a woman who kept secrets for sport.
When the crowd quieted, the Duchess thanked the hall and motioned. Dishes came, music rose, and a girl in a golden dress sang. I tried to be small and careful.
After the formal parts, the prince—Valentino—walked through with soldiers and a serious look. He met my eyes. He paused like a man seeing some small wrongness he couldn’t name. For a second, the world narrowed to him and me.
“You are Mia Lewis?” he asked, voice low.
“Yes.” My heart slammed. My knee loosened like a hinge.
“I heard you were hurt.” He looked at me like he’d seen a scar. Not the one on my forehead—something else. “Who cared for you?”
“My stepmother,” I said. I watched his face change like a cloud. He nodded once, like he believed me and did not.
Later, in the courtyard when the moon rose fat and white, he found me near a garden archway and stepped close.
“You don’t look like the type who begs fate to be kind,” he said soft.
“Most people around me pretend to be kind,” I said. I kept my hands folded. “They are not.”
He tilted his head. “You are new here.” He looked at the crowd then back at me. “Stay away from men who are cruel.”
“You are the cruel one,” I said before I could stop myself. “You beat a girl once.”
His mouth sharpened. “I do not forgive insolence.”
“But you did it. You left someone for dead.” I said it like a fact.
Valentino’s face was unreadable. “She provoked me.”
“She was a child who admired you from the street,” I said. “Why would you…?”
He swallowed. “That was a long time ago.”
“You left her broken,” I said. The words felt like stepping on glass. “And my body paid for it.”
He looked at my hands and saw the red cord. He leaned closer. “What is that?”
“It’s mine,” I said. My voice was a wire. “It saves me.”
He studied the cord like it might tell him a life. “Then keep it.”
Valentino’s shadow crossed me and passed. He left before I could say the one thing I wanted: Why hurt someone who asked only to see you? Why be a man who struck a girl?
A week later, news from the northern warfront whispered through the court. Valentino took soldiers out to face an enemy called the Yelir. The crown sent men and a new young general to join him. Everyone said the prince would return a hero or a coffin.
The war unfolded like a book whose ending you dread. Valentino’s victories and defeats landed in the papers. Rumors crawled: a new commander would come and Victor will be honored. The court shifted like a table of cards.
In the Kelly house, life narrowed to small cruelties. Nicole Bolton and Brianna Faure (the other maid) took to stealing silver and voguing like they were queens. I kept quiet and lorded in the nights over my garden. Each moon I brought gifts for the household—fresh eggs, dry herbs—to make myself useful and less suspected. I had a plan.
One night, when Nicole strutted in with a stolen red hairpin that shimmered oddly, I readied my moment.
“Where did you get that?” I asked loud enough for the kitchen to hear.
She smirked. “It’s mine. Found it in the pantry.”
“Really?” I stood.
“Yes. Want it?”
I walked across the yard. My steps were plain. I grabbed her wrist.
“You stole it,” I said.
She laughed and struck me with her broom.
I did what the body had forgotten. I moved with trained speed, a flash of a leg to her ribs, a controlled push to the back. She landed with a hard cry. The maids came running, shocked. I didn’t stop.
“This is payback,” I said, three words a little world of grit.
Karen rushed out in a silk robe like a woman who never did hard work in her life. “What in God’s name—”
“I’ll tell her story,” I said. I lifted the hairpin and flicked the tiny light inside. It stung like truth. “Take a look.”
Karen took it and saw the faint pulse of light. Her face lost the last of its softness. “Where did you get—”
“From under your bed,” I said. “From the things you thought we’d never find.”
Before she could answer, I shouted toward the courtyard, “Bring brothers! Bring whoever! My grandmother, come see!”
Hands moved. The maids collected. The household stood like a theater full of faces.
“You lied,” I said, once all eyes were on Karen. “You said you loved me so you could control the story. You told them I was wild so you could rule me.”
Karen’s face became a mask of practiced injury. “How dare you—”
“Enough!” Joan’s voice cut like a blade. “Show me.”
The chest of stolen goods came out: necklaces, coins, this red hairpin with a faint light, a folded letter—evidence that Karen had bought favors, bribed officials to keep quiet, and taken items from the poor. My proof came from the garden—some things I’d been saving. The yard buzzed.
Karen’s face reddened. “This is slander!”
“Is it?” I said. I let the small items scatter on the ground. The servants who had been seeking favor with Karen shifted. Veronica, who had smiled earlier with practiced syrup, stood frozen.
“Mother,” Veronica blurted out, voice small. “She’s—”
“You helped hide it?” Joan demanded.
“No—” Veronica started.
“Lock her up,” Karen hissed. “This insolent child attacks me?” She tried to turn the tide.
But the proof was a small army. The house watched, jaw open, as Joan turned a cold eye on Karen. “Bring the steward. This will be examined.”
Nicole Bolten seethed on the ground, lucky to be alive. Brianna trembled. The household that had mocked me now watched as the game changed. I had turned a small weapon—my knuckle, my memory, my space—into truth.
They led Karen away under suspicion. The old maids who had laughed now cried. Joan looked at me with something that might have been new: curiosity.
“You acted like this to teach me?” she asked, voice all curious.
“No,” I said. “I did it so I could live.”
She watched me hard, then nodded like a judge. “You will be watched. But if you will behave, I will not have you cast out.”
Days later, word came that Valentino returned, badly wounded but alive. The court yelled, papers shouted different claims. The crown removed a title from Valentino—but not his fire.
A month passed, and the house changed. Karen was punished, but not exiled. The maids were moved. I searched myself in a mirror and saw someone who was not just the spoiled brat of old stories. The garden fed me; it healed me. It gave me ideas.
I had medicine, and I had a plan. I walked into the town market with a basket of herbs under an old cloak. People called me a noble. I smiled and sold herbs quietly.
“You don’t look like the kind to sell,” said a woman who bought tisanes for a coughing child.
“I like to help,” I said. “And I have a way.”
Word spread slowly. A soldier from the prince’s retinue stopped by and bought teas for his men. When an epidemic hit the soldiers near the barracks, I slipped herbs and salves, worked through the night, and the sick grew better quicker than officials expected.
One morning, Valentino himself walked into my stall.
“You are the girl who sings too loud at the palace.” He said it low, like a private thing.
“You are the man who commands and scares people,” I said.
He smiled without teeth. “And you sold herbs to my men.”
“They listened,” I said. “They lived.”
He looked at the small knot of red thread at my wrist, the silver glint of its lock. “That cord,” he said. “Is that why you heal?”
“It’s a secret,” I said. “Like the other one you keep.”
He laughed and then, for a moment, looked very tired. “I never knew what I wanted before war. I thought fear would make me strong. It didn’t. It took things.”
“Then take something back,” I told him. “Take care of what you keep.”
He stared at me like he wanted to ask who I was—what I had been before this life. He had a soldier’s mind and a lonely man’s hands. “Will you come to the hospital tomorrow?” he asked.
“No promises,” I said. “But I will be there.”
The next day I treated soldiers. Valentino sat with a cup of weak broth and watched me work with a gentleness no one expected.
“I heard you can grow anything in your small place,” he said.
“It’s not small to me,” I said. “It’s the only thing that keeps me.”
He nodded. “You keep people alive.”
I looked up at him. “You killed a girl once.”
He flinched. “You hold that like a blade.”
“You have a choice to change,” I said. “If you want to not be the man who hurt girls, you can start now.”
He looked as if I’d offered him a map. “How?”
“Try being patient for once,” I said. “Look at a person twice before you judge. It’s a small start.”
So he tried. He came to the garden once, under a night sky that had no sound but the soft rust of leaves. He did not speak much. He sat and watched my hands tend roots. He came because the place smelled like truth. He came because the red cord made him curious.
“You can tell people things,” he said. “You can step out of a life and make a new one.”
“You say that like a man who can do it easily,” I said.
“Because I saw you do it,” he answered. “You took care of a garden and hid it and let nothing in. I admire that.”
He said the word like a confession. I felt heat in the hollow of my chest.
Weeks turned into a quiet rhythm. I taught him the names of plants. He showed me the names of loyalty and pain. When the court tried to shame him, he stood straighter. When whispers returned that I was a witch who made soldiers healthy, I laughed and sold more herbs.
And then one winter evening, Joan called me to the main hall. She looked at me as if she wore a crown of iron.
“You have done right by the family,” she said. “And by the city. You have brought credit.”
“Then I will ask for one thing,” I said. “I want to leave, to rent a small shop, to work with these herbs and help people. I will pay back what I owe.”
She looked at me for a long minute. “You will not be cast out?”
“No,” I said. “I will go. But I must do it myself. I will buy a cottage in the market. I will open a small apothecary.”
She watched me. Then she turned, and the old anger cracked like thin ice. “If you leave, the house will have less scandal.”
“I will not be the scandal,” I said. “I will be myself.”
She surprised me by nodding. “Then go. But keep the red cord. It is your sin and your power.”
I took the money I’d earned by selling herbs at the market and rented a tiny room by the river. I filled it with jars and jars of dried roots from the garden. I hired Haven to come live with me. She had eyes that held truth.
The town heard of my shop. People came with coughs and fevers and broken limbs. I treated them with tea and poultice. Valentino brought wounded men and sometimes stayed to watch me work. He did not command then. He sat with his elbows on his knees like a man who had learned patience.
One day the court turned against Karen for real. A stolen letter showed how she had planned to sell lands for profit and slander old neighbors to keep their gold. Joan gave her dowry to the poor and had Karen stripped of titles. The household rearranged. People watched me with kinder eyes.
News came from the front. The enemy rose again. Valentino rode out a final time. He returned after black weeks, brown with war dirt and softer with age.
“You did not break,” he said when he came to my apothecary and set dripping mud on my doorstep. His voice sounded like a man who had been tested.
“I did not break,” I said. He sat on the stool and watched me press herbs.
“You could ask for things,” he said.
“What would I ask?” I lifted a jar and handed him a bowl.
“Not that,” he said. “Stay. Let me be someone who keeps you.”
I looked down at the red cord. It lay coiled at my wrist like a small sun.
“You want me to be someone you keep?” I asked.
“Yes,” he said. “I want to be the kind of man who opens doors instead of closing them.”
“Promises are easy,” I said.
“So are tries,” he answered.
That winter, when frost wrote lines on the window, he tried. He learned to bring me tea and to carry firewood when I had none. He argued once about prices in the market and then apologized and bought me a bundle of lavender. People said we made a good pair: a man who had fought and a woman who had a secret garden.
Months later, the Duchess Catalina visited my shop with a court of women and a daughter who wore silk like armor. She had come to see the apothecary that kept soldiers alive.
“You saved men,” she said. “You did good.”
I bowed. When she left, Valentino took my hand. His fingers were warm.
“You will not be forced,” he said. “If you want to leave, I will not bind you.”
“I plan to stay,” I said. I smiled like a person who had built a small, steady house.
We did not rush. We learned each other like two slow books. He learned not to touch without asking, not to assume. I learned to trust him with small things—keys, bread, a shawl. Love came like a plant pushed through earth: slow, a little surprising, strong when it found light.
Word of my apothecary reached the Duchess’s palace. The Duchess invited me to teach women in the palace how to handle herbs. I stood in the palace garden and showed them basil and willow bark and how to wrap a wound.
“Why teach them?” Valentino asked once at my door.
“Because power is less sharp when spread,” I said.
He put his arm around my shoulders. “You are making the world softer.”
“And you are learning to be kind,” I said. “We change each other.”
On a clear spring morning, Valentino knelt in front of me in the little shop. He had no great words of sweeping promise. He had only something small and true.
“Mia,” he said—my name made his voice softer—“will you come and be with me? Not as a prize, not as a pawn, but as my equal. Will you stay?”
I looked at the red cord. It had kept my life. It had revealed a garden that mended me. It had given me independence. It had also given me the courage to fight back and the chance to walk away.
“Yes,” I said. “I will stay.”
I did not need a crown. I had a shop and a garden and a red thread that bound the world to me. Valentino took my hand. He did not ask to own me. He asked to keep me safe and to be kept in return.
We stood in the doorway. Haven cut a peach from the branch in the garden and offered it like a small blessing. Joan came to visit sometimes, still stiff and old but softer at the edges. Veronica and Janiyah Popov—my rivals—learned to bow and nod and stop calling me names.
The red cord remained on my wrist. I tied it tighter once in a while when I was afraid. It was a loop of fate that I had not expected. The final scene is simple: I closed the apothecary for the night, set the lock, and stepped into the garden with Valentino’s hand in mine.
“Do you remember your old life?” he asked.
“Some,” I answered. “Not enough to make me want it back.”
He pulled me closer. “Good. Stay, then.”
“Forever?” I teased.
“For now,” he said. Then he kissed me, quick and soft, as if sealing a promise we would keep together, a small honest thing in a world of loud crowns.
The red cord lay warm under my sleeve. The garden breathed. I had a life that belonged to me.
The End
— Thank you for reading —