Face-Slapping14 min read
The Substitute’s Quiet War
ButterPicks19 views
I remember the day he promised to marry me as if it were a clean, bright scar. The words were light, and the world around us tilted on a hinge made of an impossible future. Then the white-faced woman who had left for study abroad stepped off an airplane and smiled into my life like she had always owned it.
"Giselle," he said that night, and his voice folded like paper into a drawer.
I kept my smile anyway.
"You don't have to leave," I told her, though she already had the house key in her hand.
"Please," she said to me, with that exact softness that cost others their calm. "Molly, sit down. This is just an awkward morning."
I had been "Molly Duncan" in Axl Martinelli's life for five years, a shadow tailored to the right shape. My real name was Kaya Simpson — a name I had buried like a letter to which no one ever responded. I lived in the gap left by a woman they called Giselle Richards.
When Giselle returned, perfectly late to fit into the narrative she'd always expected, the office filled with the kind of hum that precedes a small storm. I stood in the doorway and played the part I'd practiced until my chest ached.
"Assistant Duncan, you heard me," Axl said to the room. "Everyone except the essential staff can go."
"Of course," I answered, eyes on the floor.
Giselle approached with a smile that was crafted like a pearl. "Molly, you've been here a long time," she purred, more a patting of ownership than a compassion. "Axl has been so… generous to have you."
I let a tear escape on cue and felt deliciously clean.
"Please," I whispered. "Don't make me leave. I'm just— I just wanted to be near Mr. Martinelli a little longer."
"You will go now," Axl said.
Giselle folded herself into a little imperious laugh. "He said he would marry me."
He didn't look at me when he said, "I said I will marry her."
She tried to look hurt for half a beat, then anger tightened the edges of her mouth.
"Out," she commanded.
I left obediently. I had rehearsed this exit until my legs remembered the exact weight of each step. I had rehearsed the vomit that would follow in the stairwell. I had rehearsed the hollow, awful quiet in the bathroom afterward.
I was only in his orbit for one reason. I carried a debt inside me like a match waiting to be struck. My brother, Beau Poulsen, had been crushed under a car's wheel long ago — an accident that had all the signature smudges of a planned collision. The person who had that hand in our lives wore Giselle's name like armor.
"I am here for Beau," I told nobody, minutes before I stepped into the elevator with Axl and let my chest shrink again.
"Are you well?" Everett Roberts, the lawyer who had slipped me paperwork and a bank card more times than he had smiled, asked quietly later.
"I'm fine," I lied. "I have to be."
Everett's eyes were an old map. "Kaya," he said, using the name I almost refused to keep. "We have resources. We have proof."
Proof. The word warmed the bone where grief sat cold and waiting.
"You won't let her walk," I promised.
His hand rested on mine. "I won't let justice fall into cheap pockets. But you can't do this alone."
"I don't intend to." My voice was small and steady. "I intend to watch her fall."
When Giselle sashayed into Axl's arms at family dinners and charity galas, no one saw my hands moving behind the curtains. When she placed her head on his shoulder and whispered, "We belong to each other," I whispered back into the dark, "Soon."
"You are very brave," Everett said once, looking at me with something like tenderness and something like fear.
"Bravery costs," I answered. "And I have no more to spend than a widow's handful."
The pregnancy came like another strategic card. I did not welcome it — I had not wanted Beau's child to carry the weight of the world — yet it became a keystone. Axl could not deny me proximity now. A pregnant woman, even a substitute, presses herself into places that others will not touch.
"Don't take risks," Everett warned when he found me after I'd been sick again in the kitchen.
"I'm careful," I said. "I always am."
"Then be careful with your heart as well."
"I've kept it caged for five years," I told him.
"You are not a weapon to wield against the living, Kaya," he said.
"Nor do I worship the dead." I hated the gentle primer of his advocacy. "I will avenge Beau."
Giselle pivoted through public life like a practiced dancer. "You look tired, Molly," she said once in the pantry, as if she could smother me with concern. "You should rest."
"Your place is with Axl," I said mildly. "We are all tired sometimes."
She flinched like someone struck. "You speak oddly today."
"Odd is my new normal," I said.
"Don't make this hard," she whispered. "You and I don't have to fight. We can both be part of Axl's life."
"Or not." I smiled and left.
In those small spaces I collected evidence. I was careful. I watched the angles of cars, the tone of voice in late-night calls, the way Giselle ordered men around like chess pieces. I recorded, wrote, photographed. I traded empty smiles for incriminating proof.
"You have been very patient, Kaya," Everett said one late night when he shoved another envelope into the pocket I'd worn thin. "How is the child?"
"It is still a plan," I said.
"Plans can be cruel," he murmured. "We are ready, but the world is not an honest place."
"Then we will make it honest."
The banquet was Axl's family's most opulent night of the year — the anniversary of the family's larger-than-life patriarch. Axl wanted to finalize a delicate acquisition tonight, and Giselle was meant to stand luminous by his side and present the image of an unbreakable dynasty.
I walked into the ballroom like someone with all the world's small stars in a pocket. Everett had given me back my real name for the night — "Kaya Simpson" — on the invitation. For once I felt entire in that syllable.
"You will want to watch quietly," Everett told me.
"No," I said, and the word surprised him.
"You are sure?"
"Yes."
We both knew what it meant: I would either open the door or hold the key.
The crystal in the chandeliers leaked light like a slow spill. Servers moved across the room like a graceful tide. People smiled and raised glasses and made wounds of their own in polite conversations.
"Lovely evening," Giselle said later, velvet and precise. "Our family has come a long way."
"Yes," Axl began. "Tonight we celebrate—"
"—the truth," I interrupted, stepping into a pool of light I hadn't invited myself into.
The hall went quiet as if a hand had been placed over its mouth.
"Aren't we tired of secrets?" I asked, voice small. "Aren't we tired of arranging the dead like ornaments on the mantel?"
Giselle's laugh was sharp. "Who are you to—
"You are Giselle Richards," I said loudly. "You are the woman who drove a man to his death six years ago."
Every head swivelled toward the stage like a flock with one bone. Axl's face was a blade of winter. Giselle's eyes, which had once been cool mare's eyes, flickered.
"Stop," she hissed. "You— this is—
"You killed Beau Poulsen," I continued. "You and your hired hands. You called it an accident. You smiled when the news buried the truth."
"You are mad," she snapped, and her voice trembled like someone being strangled by surprise.
"No," I said. "I am ready."
I moved my hand toward the small remote buried in my clutch. Everett's fingers brushed mine as if on instinct; he did not speak. We had rehearsed the moment without speaking the words aloud.
On the large screen behind the head table, a video appeared. It started with a grainy street-camera clip — night, a car turning too quickly, a figure stumbling into the light. The footage looped and caught the wrong angle last time; tonight it had sound. A voice, rough and male, negotiated money. "Make it look clean," someone said. "Make it an accident."
Voices are small until they are recorded and played back.
Giselle's face drained from color into the wax of panic. "Turn it off! Who gave you the right—"
"Watch," I whispered.
The next clip was a phone call. It was someone with a familiar laugh and a command that matched Giselle's public certainty. "It will cost a bit more," the male voice said. "But we've done it before. She pays. We close the case."
The murmurs rolled through the room. Phones came up like mirrors. One man said, "This can't be— how—"
"It is her voice," said a woman near the back.
"Turn it off!" Giselle managed to scream when the recording reached the clear, chilling line: "Are you sure there will be no traces? You removed everything, right? No one will talk?"
I pulled the microphone closer. "On the night Beau died there was no accident," I said. "There was a plan. A man who should be alive is dead because your family treated a life as a rounding error."
"You have no right!" Axl barked, an animal caught between two instincts— to protect and to hide.
"You hid it before," I said. "You paid people. You moved evidence. You called it 'ten thousand dollars and we are done' like a hospital bill. Beau was a boy who celebrated my graduation. He was my brother. He was stolen from me."
Giselle's hands clawed at the tablecloth. Cameraphones zoomed in on her face. "It wasn't me! It wasn't— I didn't—"
"You admitted it," another clip played, unforgiving as a judge. Her recorded voice bargaining with a go-between, promises exchanged like currency: "If you do this, I'll make sure their mouths close. Don't make me regret helping you."
She was white, lips gone thin. I had watched her steadiness unravel in the private of my notes. Tonight was the unveiling of her stitches.
"I'm telling lies!" Giselle's voice swung to mania. "I'm innocent!"
"Aren't we all the same until someone uncovers the truth?" I asked. "You had a home because my family had less and because the Martinellis thought a single use of money could cover a life."
People edged back. The chandeliers hummed on their wires.
On Axl's face, for the first time, I saw ownability crack. "Giselle," he said, "explain."
"You— you—" she wept now, not from sorrow but from the first warm understanding that the game had slipped. "They told me it would be done right. They said the witness would only lie. They told me—"
"Who told you?" The question came from a man who had a right to know. The question was small and it was terrible.
The initial viewer not only gasped at the evidence but watched Giselle's posture collapse. Her arrogance crumpled like a ticket. There was the shifting of a predator into prey. She stared at Axl the way someone stares at an old photograph, trying to pick out the day when happiness began to curdle.
"Do you deny you spoke to these men?" I asked.
"No, I—" she began, but then shook her head. "I didn't mean for anyone to die. I thought—"
"You arranged." My voice was a small knife. "You thought you could buy a return."
A child near the ballroom's edge began to cry. Someone murmured about calling the police. A dozen phones began to beam the scene into private worlds.
"Stop recording," Giselle begged, but cameras do not obey private begging.
"Arrest her," someone shouted.
She went from triumphant to terrified in the angle of a breath. "I didn't kill anyone!" she screamed. "You don't understand— they told me it would look like an accident—"
"That's a confession on record," Everett said into my ear, voice as steady as law can be. "We have causation. We have admission. We have witnesses."
Giselle's face went through the stages the scriptbooks teach: step one, denial; step two, rage; step three, begging. They came in flood, jagged and loud. "I will pay more! I'll give anything! Don't— don't—"
By then the first of the police had arrived. They moved into the room with the small gentle authority of people who guide tragedy into process. "Please calm down," one officer said to Giselle. "We have statements to take."
The woman who'd been nearest me earlier pointed a shaking finger. "She did it!" she cried. "She— she had them take the witness out of the way before—"
Phones raised higher, faces leaned in. Someone recorded Giselle's face as she went cold, as the weight of inches and years pressed on her shoulders. People began to clap like a strange percussive mourning. Some shook their heads so hard the jeweled necklaces leaned.
"Don't touch me!" Giselle screamed when a hand tried to guide her toward the door. Her gait was a listless, wild thing. She was torn between the old safety of money and the new clarity of metal cuffs.
"Please," she begged the crowd, voice suddenly small. "Please, it's a mistake— I can fix it, I can—"
"Where were you when Beau Poulsen bled out on the street?" I asked quietly.
Silence cut the air. People craned for space where compassion might still hide.
"You had other men do the dirty work," I told the crowd. "You thought your money could bury ash. Tonight we dug into it and found the bones."
The crowd responded in a thousand small ways: gasps, the shuttering of phones, the rustle of dealer suits. Someone started to chant "Justice" like a sliver of weather.
Giselle's mask came off entirely then. She was no longer the rich girl who walked into a room and made it submit. She was the frantic person who had made a choice and now watched it come home. She threw herself to her knees, palms flat against the carpet, and pressed her forehead to the floor.
"I'm sorry," she wept. "I'll do anything. I'll give you money, everything— I'll give you everything—"
"You took everything from them," I said. "You cannot give it back."
Cameras recorded the wetness of her pleading. The people around her recorded their own astonishment and the way the honeyed world of wealth cracked into panic.
At least three people dropped to the floorlaughing with hysteria and then crying. A woman behind me sharpened her words as if she were slicing through the final sugar coating: "Do you remember the child? Do you remember the boy who laughed at the sea? He is buried and you bartered his death as if buying a trinket."
Giselle looked up at last, and I saw the film of denial evaporate from her eyes. "It wasn't supposed to go like that," she breathed. "It wasn't supposed—"
"It never is," Axl said. His voice had the curdled quality of someone who'd been told his lineage was a fiction.
The police led her away. She screamed through the corridor and yelled accusations at the people photographing her degrading descent. People pointed cameras. People took pictures. People shouted what they'd seen to other attendees and calls were made; friends who had drained other moments then looked at datasheets and at each other like shut men at an altar.
"She will be prosecuted," Everett said when the noise fell into the hush of process. "We have recorded confessions and evidence. She will stand trial."
The crowd's reaction passed from heat to a strange, drained satisfaction. It was not joy, not exactly; it was a kind of exhausted righteousness. I watched Giselle through the glass until the doors closed. For a moment she barreled her head into the door as if to crash it open again.
Someone near the exit murmured, "That was beautiful."
Another woman shouted, "You took too long."
Axl did not meet my eyes. He had a new, different kind of ruin across his face — one I recognized almost intimately. He had built a palace of arrangements and found it lacquered by public rot.
"Why didn't you tell me?" he asked, the sentence small and private.
"You didn't want to hear," I said. "You were married to an idea."
He swallowed hard. "Maybe," he admitted. "But I helped make the bed. I will make it so she faces the law."
"Do it well," Everett said.
The night after the banquet, the papers called it a scandal. The video spread like a stain. Some people who had once laughed at less important things deleted old images and posted earnest ones. Some defended Giselle in weak proclamations. Some were stunned into silence.
Giselle's punishment was not just the physical clink of cuffs. It was the collapse of the image she had used to buy impunity. She faced the judges of public opinion and fate. She lost guests, benefactors, and places that used to bend for her entrance. People took their jewelry to her club and returned it like penance. Her private contacts pretended not to remember the corridors where they'd once slept in her good graces.
The justice system moved at the plodding pace of law, but the social punishment was immediate and comprehensive. Once the front doors opened, gossip multiplied. Former friends sent messages that sounded like apologies. Former lovers avoided eye contact in the street. Sponsors terminated deals overnight. She walked through the world like a woman who no longer had a place on its maps.
I never liked the look of pity. I had wanted acknowledgement.
"She will not be let off," Everett said, sitting beside me with an apple and that stubbornly gentle face.
"I don't want pity," I told him. "I don't want her to vanish quietly. I want the record."
"You have it," he said. "And the record will follow the law."
There were nights later when I dreamt that Beau was at my shoulder, smiling like he had the right to. "You did it right," he would say, the way small boys say everything is fixed if you wave a magic stick.
"You would have hated the banquets," I told him in my sleep.
"Not if the food was good," he said.
The world, I learned, did not instantly right itself after public exposure. People at the top still hid things. Money still lubricated truth in ways the law sometimes could not reach.
But the banquet was the hinge. It swung the door, and then a chain of small honest processes began to ratchet open.
Giselle's public collapse was the first of many consequences, and it had everything the hunger inside me wanted to see: her face changing from triumph to disbelief to pleading; the phones showing the betrayal; the crowd— witnesses—no longer willing to be polite. That was my revenge, hand-delivered with quiet accuracy.
After the banquet, Axl's behavior changed. Sometimes he stood at the window staring at the city with his hands balled at his sides. Sometimes he would find me in the kitchen and say, "You could have told me."
"You could have listened," I said.
"Are you satisfied?" he'd ask once, the night thin with the sound of distant traffic.
"No," I said. "Satisfaction is not mine to possess."
"Then what do you want?" He turned to look at me with a look that was no longer just anger but an earnestness that made my chest ache.
"I wanted Beau to be remembered," I said.
He shut his eyes like a man trying to shut out light. "I will not let the family hide this," he promised. "Not anymore."
He did what he could. He announced internal investigations, offered to aid prosecutors, and met with media handlers. He stood, for the first time, on the side of exposure rather than concealment. It was an imperfect and late contrition, but it opened other doors. The stockholders demanded explanations. Some were angry, some were fascinated.
Months later, Giselle took the stand. She pleaded and wept. She blamed others. She tried, with the cunning of someone schooled in survival by privilege, to make bargains.
The court scene was a mosaic of small torments. Members of the public lined the benches, a dozen cameras trained like hawks. Everett sat with me every day.
"You are tired," he would say when I looked cracked, when my hands trembled from holding on.
"I am," I admitted.
"Then you can rest when it's over."
There is a kind of slow justice sometimes— one that moves through paperwork, depositions, and delicate interrogations. It is not always loud. It is not always satisfying like a chorus. But when Giselle finally heard the judge's words, when the gavel cracked like a bone into a carved table, I felt the world tilt back a fraction.
"You will never replace what was lost," the judge told her. "Nor can money restore life."
She had thought otherwise.
After the trial I left Axl's house and stepped into a smaller life. I changed my name back to Kaya Simpson in the register. Everett stayed in touch. He arranged for my child's legal status and, later, for a small trust to ensure our immediate needs were met. He asked for nothing; he had always wanted less than what he gave.
"Will you be okay?" Everett asked on the day I left the big house behind.
"I will be," I said. "I am going somewhere Beau used to like. I need to see the sea."
He smiled the way a sunlit man does. "Send a letter when you can."
"I will," I promised.
I wrote one later, a long letter to Everett that he didn't have to read but would keep. I wrote to thank him for keeping his hands steady and for replanting my name in my life. I told him I planned to visit the places Beau and I had once said we'd see, and that perhaps one day I would teach a small child to look at the sunrise and not be afraid.
When people asked me later whether I had wanted Axl, I would always say the truth.
"I wanted a truth," I would say.
He had given me something complicated — not love in a tidy bow, but an end to a particular hiding. He had not been blameless. He had not been my boyfriend in old novels. He was a man with power and, in the end, a man who could be pushed into a right.
As for Giselle, she lived out a sentence that matched the measure of a city that had once taken a life as casually as a winter storm. She faded from parties and high fashion, and new names rose like tide foam. That was part of what I had to take. The world moves on.
The last thing Beau said to me in my dreams was that he hoped the sea would be warm.
So I went to it.
On a quiet morning I sat on a small pier with my child asleep in my lap and Everett's note folded in my pocket. I watched the light gather like coins along the water. The past did not vanish. It became a map I used to find small roads.
A man with a camera once asked why I wasn't angrier. I told him, "Anger is heavy. I have a small child. I prefer light." He wrote it down and posted it. I don't know if the sentence made sense to anyone but me.
"Will you ever forgive her?" someone asked me once in the little cafe at the edge of town.
"Forgiveness is not mine to give or to take," I said. "Only the law was given the right to adjudicate, and people were given the right to bear witness. I did both."
He nodded.
It is odd to end a war quietly. There are no trumpets. There are only the continuing days where you make bread, change diapers, and let your heart learn the way of small, generous things.
On the pier I looked at my child's sleeping face and thought, Beau would have liked him. I thought of Everett's steady presence and Axl's late contrition. I thought of Giselle sitting in an empty room and the taste of a justice that came not as a grand blaze but as many small, precise flames, each one lighting what was dark.
I pressed my hand to my belly and felt the tiny, patient rhythm of what I had already promised to protect.
"Beau was right about the sea," I whispered to the wind. "He liked the way it didn't pretend to be anything other than water."
The city behind me hummed like a thing that had gone on, with scandals and kindness and new faces. I did not care for fanfare anymore. I cared for the clean cadence of daily life. I watched the line where water met sky and felt — finally — that the horizon could be an offering rather than a threat.
And then I walked home.
The End
— Thank you for reading —