Regret14 min read
The Suitcase, the A4, and the Night I Stopped Waiting
ButterPicks12 views
"I want a divorce."
"Why now?" Franklin Craig asked like the words were a cold measurement he couldn't accept. He stood in the living room with his hands folded, the same posture he took when negotiating a client. The sunlight slid across the floor and did nothing to warm him.
"It doesn't feel right anymore," I said, and meant it the way you mean a bruise you no longer want to press at. I had given ten years to a life with him. That sounded like a small fortune until it stopped buying anything.
"You don't say something like that without giving me a fight," he said.
"I don't want a fight." I put a box on the armchair and zipped it closed. "I want out."
He watched the box like someone watching a clock. "Are you certain?"
"Yes."
We signed the paper at the registry, because there are rules and one must obey them even when the heart is tired. There was a thirty-day cooling period. Thirty days felt longer than any sentence I had been given in a courtroom. I packed what I could carry in one suitcase and walked out. Franklin stood in the doorway and did not stop me.
"Why would you leave the ring?" he asked later, as if a metal circle carried more truth than nights of silence.
"It wasn't truth," I said. "It was pattern."
I drove to a nearby hotel and sat on the bed with the suitcase at my feet. The sheets were new. The neighborhood noise reduced to a distant hum. My phone buzzed. Blair Vogel had sent a silly message about a line from an old poem and a picture of her on set.
"I love three things in the world," she wrote. "The Sun, the Moon and U."
"Classic Blair," I typed back and deleted it. I didn't feel like confessing why I had come alone. I wasn't even ready to tell myself.
Blair and I had been friends since university, before the career lights fell heavier on her. She was the kind of brilliant actress who could make a single look on camera rewrite an entire scene. She was also reckless in the way that makes one dangerous for the people who love them: ferocious, unforgettable, and not built for long quiets.
When Franklin found me in that hotel, drenched from rain and very fed up, he walked up like a man who had rehearsed his lines.
"Your car?" I asked.
"At the shop."
He handed me a tube of cream that he had fished from a plastic bag. He knew which brands I used the way a detective knows a bad alibi.
"Why did you come back?" I asked when he stood too close.
"Because I'm still your husband," he said.
"Not for long."
He sighed. "We can be practical. We can talk."
And then he did what he always did when the words became too complicated: he fixed something. He opened my suitcase, found the rash cream, and applied it to my back with the calm certainty of someone operating machinery.
"You can't always leave," he said when he sat down beside me on the hotel bed. "That's not how commitments work."
"Who asked you to fix my commitments?" I said, and laughed because nothing else came.
He kissed me like an apology that wasn't an apology. "Come home," he said. "We can go back to normal."
"Which normal?" I asked.
Before the answer could fall, the room rang with the kind of truth that runs a kitchen timer: my exhale. I had practiced leaving for months. Standing there, I realized I'd been practicing escape routes in my head for longer than I'd properly loved.
Two days later, Franklin drove me to the airport and then didn't come to see me off. I sat on the shuttle and thought of the apartment we had filled with half-made compromises and shared bills. I thought of the library where we had met — me reaching for a book on the second shelf, him stepping in like a human ladder — and how the world had seemed fuller then. I thought of the way my mother valued clear, acceptable outcomes. I thought of how much of myself I had given up without realizing.
Blair's assistant met me at the arrivals. "You're late," she said with the fond cruelty of someone who knows they will be forgiven for everything.
"Traffic," I said.
"She told you to rest," the assistant said. "But you look like you hiked a mountain."
"That's modern travel," I said.
Blair opened the car door like a comet. "You, my friend, look like you need actresses, scripts, and a lot of spicy soup," she said, and ushered me into her world.
On the set there were lights and moves and the kind of noise that distracts a mind from worrying. Nicolas Mendes — the actor who had been orbiting Blair's new project — walked by with the small, charming arrogance of someone who has a face people will pay to watch.
"I remember him," I whispered to Blair. "The one who looks like he should be the prince in every show."
"That's him," she said. "He's the one who smiles and gets the internet to smile back."
We watched rehearsals. People wept at the end of a scene because Blair had taught them how to cry in the most useful way. I laughed at a joke and felt small, like a coin in a fountain.
Ismail Ricci, a lawyer who had been known to us both since college, sat across the coffee tent and watched me with the quiet gravity of someone cataloging evidence.
"Emily," he said when I went to him. "You're marooned. Maps?"
"Just a hostel," I said.
"Come to dinner with us," he offered. "There's room for one more at my table."
I had never expected the legal mind to be tender. He spoke with a kind, practical warmth. "You don't have to decide anything tonight," he said. "Decisions are not a race."
"Sometimes they feel like they are," I told him.
"Make them when your hands are clean," he said.
That night I slept like a woman who had been allowed to put her head down without needing to perform resilience.
The days passed with the awkwardness of a slow-motion train wreck. Franklin called and texted with the effectiveness of someone who thought persistence was persuasion. Sometimes I opened his messages and deleted them like someone erasing blotches on a page until it felt cleaner.
"You should come home," he wrote. "We can talk. We can work."
One morning Nicolas Mendes called Ismail and asked about a legal concern. "Guard your heart," he said in a joking tone, "and your friend's heart. We're both professionals in the field of human affairs."
"Humans are messy," Ismail said. "But people also change their minds."
"Which is worse? Someone who leaves or someone who never had the courage to stay?" Nicolas asked.
"Both," Ismail replied. "Both can be killers."
I laughed when I overheard. It felt like a joke I had the right to laugh at.
Then the world shifted.
"I saw something," Blair said to me with that narrowed look that means a woman has put her detector to work. "On set. He was being too familiar with the new actress. And then he started to hide his phone."
"Who?" I asked.
"His husband," she said. "Dane Brock."
Dane Brock. The name fit like a coat — heavy and unnaturally expensive. He was the kind of producer husband who could shape a career and break it. I didn't know Dane personally, but Blair did, and when Blair said the name the room changed like a tide.
"He has a wife?" I asked.
"Yes," Blair said. "Legally. Abroad."
"Then what is he doing?" I asked.
"Helping me," Blair said. "And helping himself."
We continued to work, because work offers you a place to put grief and dressing rooms let you change costumes for your vulnerabilities.
A week after my hospital visit for a mistaken pregnancy scare — a night of panic and emptiness that resolved with a lab slip showing HCG under five — everything crumbled into the most loud, unstoppable exposure.
Blair insisted on confronting Dane in a controlled public setting. "We don't hide," she said. "We make sure the world sees it, and then the world can do the rest."
"Are you sure?" I asked. "This will blow up."
"It will," she said, "and I need it to."
We arranged a luncheon at a midtown gallery. Blair sent polite invitations to the press. She told her agent, who wanted to cancel it, that this was the only way she could find peace.
On the day of the luncheon, the room smelled of white roses and lemon oil. There were twenty seats and two cameras. We sat in the front because we were the subjects and because we wanted to watch the shadows on Dane's face. Dane arrived looking calm, like someone who expects the room to rearrange around him.
"You're killing me with this formality," he said to Blair as he sat. "This looks like a marital intervention. I'm a busy man."
"Sit," Blair said.
"Everything's fine," he continued. "Publicity, in fact, is fine. You always know how to keep things trending. Why are you staging this?"
She reached to the table and placed a folder in front of her. Her hand did not tremble. She opened it and slid one photograph to the center. The camera's lenses clicked and leaned forward like an insect.
"This is your map," Blair said. "Your trail of breadcrumbs."
Dane smiled in the way cheaters think will save them: like a strategy, not a face.
"People who write these things like to dramatize," he said. "Blair, what is this?"
"This is a marriage certificate issued in Prague," she said. "This is your passport stamp. This is your wife’s name."
He chuckled. "I don't know what game you're playing."
"You're not the type who plays games," Blair said. Her voice was cool. "You're the type who makes a business model of taking lives apart piece by piece. I am not your business. I am a person."
I stood up. My hands were small and cold. I had come to support her but what I felt was something beyond support: an urge to be witness.
"You lied," I said. "To me; to others."
"My apologies," he said, and smiled like a man who practices regret at home. "Iz nothing to see here."
Then Blair reached into the folder and took out a thin stack of printouts: bank transfers, calendar entries, images of hotel check-ins.
"Tell them about the plane tickets," she said.
He frowned. "This is harassment."
Blair slid another document across the table: there was a name in the corner — his lawyer's login, a recording of a voicemail where he suggested 'discretion' and 'external arrangements' as useful PR tools.
"Explain to us why you had a wedding in Prague and then a life here with me," Blair said.
"You can't prove that," he said. "These could be staged. Anyone can print."
"Then explain this," Blair said, and played a voice note she had on her phone. It was him, drunk, saying: "We will keep this between us. Don't ruin what we've made."
He went from confident to puzzled. He tried to reach for the phone. The room moved toward a different kind of gravity.
"Who recorded that?" he asked, in a voice that tried to sound small and confusing.
"Someone who should have been your friend," Blair said.
Dane's face, which had the pall of an executive, began a series of steps I have watched before and never wanted to catalog: first an imperial smugness, then an off-balance falter, then a nap of denial.
"You're lying," he said.
"Am I?" she asked. "Please, Dane. For the love of everything, try denying that you told me you'd leave her when you were ready. Try denying you sold me the idea of us."
Someone in the press stood and said, "Mr. Brock, what do you say?"
He looked at the cameras as if they were hostile animals, and his words were small. "This is private," he said.
"Private?" Blair repeated. "You made it public every time we signed a contract with your studio. You made it public in your decisions. You made it public in the terms you offered."
Then he smiled, thin. "This is a setup."
"Ken?" an assistant called softly. "Should we?"
"Yes," Blair said.
They had placed someone in the room to stream. The cameras were live in three different feeds. The comments began to populate on phones: "Blair Vogel exposed?" "Dane Brock denies?" "What about his Prague marriage?"
A woman near the back whispered, "Is that his international marriage certificate?" People around her were pulling out phones, the kind that move like a flock.
Dane's jaw moved. He went from denial to fury like the weather going from sun to storm. "This is extortion," he said. "You can't publish this. You will regret this."
"People like you don't know the first thing about regret," Blair said. "People like you think reputation is a lockbox."
"Stop it," he shouted. "Stop—"
He stood so fast a glass of water near his hand tipped over. Ismail got to his feet. "Dane, sit down. This isn't going to help. Talk to us."
"What do you want? To ruin me? She always wanted attention. She used me."
"Used you," Blair repeated. She set another photograph on the table — it was of a young woman in Prague, eyes tired but smiling, with a child. "Explain this little one," she said.
At hearing that, the color drained from his face and something like panic took its place. He stuttered, "I... I don't—"
"You have choices," I said. "You chose deception. You chose secrecy."
"Oh, please," he barked. "You think you can make me into a villain in front of a camera?"
"You already are one," Blair said.
Then the public part took over. A woman at a corner table took out her phone and turned on video. Another started a live stream on a social account. The room filled with the low sound of air conditioning and a thousand tiny clicks. People began to murmur and then to speak aloud, concerned and hungry and newly appointed jurors.
"Look at him," someone said. "How could he?"
"He made two lives," another said. "Two families."
Dane realized that the room was changing into an audience, then a tribunal. His face crumpled into something unready for the stage. He spun. "You're making a show out of private matters!"
"Public matters," Blair corrected. "When you sign a marriage certificate, it's public. When you feed half-truths to eight other women to keep them as convenient props, that's public."
Dane's voice dropped to a begging whisper. "Please, I didn't mean—"
"Please what?" a journalist asked. "Please explain what you meant? Please name the woman in Prague? Please tell us why you dualed two hearts?"
People were recording; comments on their feeds were outraged, incredulous, hungry. Someone held up their phone screen and it was already live—angles, close-ups, the stamped name in the certificate clear.
He shrank, then denied, then leaned over the table and, impossibly, knelt down in front of Blair and me like an actor begging for mercy in a cheap movie.
"Don't—" he said, and the word quavered into something like prayer. "Don't make this my ruin."
There were cameras and a hundred witnesses. A man in a suit whispered to him and pushed him to his feet. People around took photos. Someone applauded, not for him but for the spectacle of the truth landing.
"This is what you wanted?" Blair asked. "You wanted applause?"
He was not that arrogant anymore. He was small and raw and mortal. "I... I am sorry," he said. "I didn't think—"
"Think?" Blair snapped. "You chose this for years."
Someone had started to laugh, like a chorus. Some clapped. Some whooped. Others filmed the kneeling, the pleading, the slow fall of a man from the comfortable top of a private life into the public shrapnel of his own choices.
He begged. He offered money. He offered apologies. He held our knees like a supplicant. The scene had everything a hateful heart could want: spectacle, collapse, humiliation. Phones recorded minute by minute.
I saw faces around the room change: from curiosity to compassion to schadenfreude to the desire to protect. People argued. "It's fair," someone said. "He deserves it." Another: "Don't let them get to you, Blair."
When the police liaison called later to advise us on restraining the spread of private materials, it was too late; the internet had made the moment a permanent page. Dane Brock's humiliation was a long slow public performance: he had gone from triumph to exposure in one afternoon, and in front of people who filmed him like an exhibit.
He tried to stand tall again, but the cameras kept moving. He tried to reason, to argue proceduralities, to veil his marriage certificate as a misinterpretation. Each attempt crumbled. People who had clinked glasses with him a month ago were now lighting their phones to document his fall. Children in the room stared as if at an animal.
When he left, shoulders hunched, people made room for him as if he were a wounded animal. He turned and saw cameras, saw the crowd’s faces, saw those little glowing rectangles. He lifted his hands, as if to shield his shame. He did not look at Blair.
After the luncheon, the news spiraled. It was on feeds, in morning dials, and in overnight headlines. By sunset my phone buzzed with messages that were different in tone — practical, blunt, some sympathetic. Franklin texted: "Are you okay?"
I didn't answer immediately. I thought about how truth had been served cold and how it tasted different on different tongues. For me, the scene was radical: not for the spectacle but for the permission it gave me to stop pretending.
"Why did you do it in public?" I asked Blair later at her trailer when everyone had left.
"Because he thought he could hide behind quiet deals," she said. "Because the only language some people respond to is the sound of the world watching."
"Does it help?" I asked.
"It helps me," she said, pouring two cups of tea. "It helps others know they aren't alone."
After that day the internet did what it does: it carved opinions into quick little monuments. Blair's ratings shot up. Dane tried to issue statements. He lost partnerships. He begged on the steps of his office for discretion. He tried to claim it was a smear and then it was a misinterpretation and then he was tired and ill and unable to be the man he once wanted to be. The public ate it anyway.
Meanwhile my own life kept unspooling: hospital visits for a false positive pregnancy test, awkward dinners with my parents who loved me but could not understand why I wouldn't simply "settle," and quiet nights when Franklin's messages arrived like patient rain—persistent but unremarkable.
One evening Franklin stood in my kitchen with an A4 sheet in his hand.
"I prepared something," he said.
"What is it?"
"A draft." He offered me a page. "Property. Accounts. Logic."
He smiled like a man who believed in the sanctity of forms. "Sign it. It'll be clean."
I looked at the document. It was an attempt at fairness by a man who had thought that reason and law could replace feeling. I signed my name and then tore the page in half at the spine and crumpled it, just to see if the sound of tearing could sever habit.
"This isn't about money," I said. "This is about the fact I spent ten years being the place where someone left their coat."
He backed away as if I had hit him. "You could have asked. We could have tried counseling. We could have—"
"We could have," I said. "But we didn't. We made a life that fit around your work and my tolerance."
He knelt in front of me like someone learning humility late. "Please," he said. "Give me another chance."
"Not another chance," I said. "I want to stop hoping you'll find me the same person in an old photograph."
It was not a dramatic scene for anyone else. He left that night and I slept like a person who had decided to be brave in small ways. I took the crumpled A4, smoothed it, and folded it into my wallet, not because I needed it but because I wanted a memory of how loud an unsupported plea could sound.
Weeks later, after Blair's trial by public opinion had finally slid into a slow burn of gossip, after phone feeds tired and found other monsters, I sat at a small café and reflected.
Ismail had come by. "You look like you've seen the ocean," he said.
"I saw a man fall apart in public," I said. "And I didn't feel like I needed to repair him for the world."
"Justice is a strange thing," Ismail said. "Sometimes it is private. Sometimes it is a crowd."
"Did you ever think we'd end up like this?" I asked him.
"No," he said. "But I think this is honest. You're honest now."
"Honesty takes a lot," I said.
"Not as much as pretending," he replied.
We drank and talked and, for once, my stories didn't come with apologetic clauses. I told him about the library and the time Franklin had shoed on his lap and how their hands fit when they were younger. He listened like a friend who had been patient with the slow proof of human things.
"Will you ever want to marry again?" he asked.
"I don't know," I said. "I used to think marriage was a destination. Now I think it's a direction. It still might be good. It might also be a set of directions for people who like stations."
"Keep the directions in a safe place," he said, and then smiled, which warmed the café even though it was rainy outside.
Months later, after contracts signed and signatures shaken and feeds gone stale, I packed the last of my things. It was a small ceremonial thing. I slid the torn A4 — the one Franklin had made as his attempt at honesty — into a drawer in the little desk I kept in my new apartment. Above it I placed the blue hotel key I had used the first night I left. I closed the drawer and listened to the faint click of something shutting.
"Is that it?" Blair asked when she came by to help.
"For now," I said. "For now I'm going to live a life that answers me back."
She hugged me. "Good. You deserve an audience that applauds you for being alive, not for apologizing for living."
"Doesn't everyone?" I said.
She laughed. "Probably."
On the morning I finally filed the final papers and stood at the registry bench with the clerk looking at our signatures and folded forms, I thought about the library shelves and the time when a tall man had helped me with a book. I thought about the way we are patient with the idea of people becoming what we first saw in them. I thought also about Dane Brock, kneeling and filmed, and how public humiliation never heals but sometimes forces the lie out into the light.
I left the registry with a tiny, formal stamp in my pocket. I did not feel triumphant. I felt relieved in the way one feels after removing a splinter. The city felt same and different: the same streets and lights, but with an empty seat beside me I would no longer script.
At the door of my new apartment I placed the blue hotel key on the small hook where I kept trivial, private things. The torn A4 stayed in the drawer like evidence that I could break a pattern and not lose myself.
"Where will you go now?" Blair asked.
"Somewhere with a kitchen," I said. "And a window. And maybe a library shelf that isn't moccasined by the past."
She grinned. "Then go and eat something ridiculous. You have to live."
I opened the window and watched the street below. Someone pushed a stroller. A shopkeeper swept his front step. A dog barked once and stopped. I kept the A4 in the drawer and thought of small kindnesses I could give to myself: a decent breakfast, a book, time without the need to justify.
I slid the blue hotel key into my pocket and walked out to the sound of the city waking up. I did not step onto any cloud. I stepped onto a pavement that felt like a road I had chosen again.
The End
— Thank you for reading —