Face-Slapping17 min read
Three Million Dollars and the Thread That Unpicked Us
ButterPicks18 views
I remember the first time I thought money would fix everything.
"Put the kettle on," I told her, like I always did. "I'll be back late."
Genevieve tied the towel around her thin waist and smiled, the way she always smiled when she thought I was pleased. Her hands trembled a little when she lifted the lid. "Don't stay out too late," she said softly.
"Business," I replied, because that was the shorthand for the nights I wasn't with her any more.
She nodded, obedient as a child, as if obedience could stitch the world into order.
When I was poor, she used to slap my shoulder and say, "Carson, you dramatic fool. You'll make it." When I had nothing, she sat in our tiny room and wiped the mugs until they shone like small moons. When I failed, she went to work washing other people's dishes in a hotpot restaurant with her fingers pruned and red.
"You're not to cry today," she told me once when I came home late and smelled like burnt alcohol. "I'll make dumplings. I made them for you when you were seven and you said they tasted like heaven."
"I know," I said and lied. "I'll change."
She believed me in ways I didn't deserve.
Years later I would think of that kitchen as if it were a different planet.
"Do you remember the pink hairclip?" she asked once while we were both young and broke.
"How could I forget?" I said. "You forced me into stealing a coil of wire to buy it."
She laughed and slapped me on the shoulder. "You cried when the neighbor slapped you."
"I'm an idiot," I said.
"No. You're mine," she corrected. "You're always mine."
I forgot how to be small after I tasted success. I learned to be large in every way—cars that shone, suits that looked like armor, a voice that could carve a room into respect.
"Three million," I said to myself the night I decided to reclaim her. "Three million will put everything right."
Armani came into my life like a summer song.
"Can we meet?" she asked on video. Her face floated on my phone—a young halo of earnestness. "I want to know you better."
I laughed. "You barely know life yet."
"You're flattering me," she said. "You don't talk like a businessman. You look tired."
"Work," I said. "New project."
"You should sleep." Her eyes said she believed me. "You look older."
"You're sweet," I answered, and the word was small and dangerous.
Armani was eighteen; her voice had the urgency of someone who believed in saints. She had the kind of admiration that felt like sunlight warming the rusted angles of me.
"Be careful," she said once, after I'd snapped at a junior for a shoddy bid. "You're not a god, Carson."
"Am I so bad?" I asked, genuinely amused.
"No," she said, "but sometimes gods don't know how to carry their own weight."
I kept her at arm's length because I could. I let her come close enough to brush my world with laughter and scare her away only when she wanted more ownership than I intended to grant.
I kept Genevieve because she fit into the home I had bought—a house that smelled faintly of lemon and expensive polish. She cleaned, she embroidered, she waited by the door wearing the same freckled patience she had worn when we were ten years old.
"Put your briefcase here," she said the morning I announced another trip abroad. She stood at the hall like a sentinel. "Do you want me to tie your tie?"
"No." I smiled. "I'll handle it."
"Let me." She stepped closer, and the gesture was equal parts ritual and worship.
"You're very good at this," I said as she straightened the tie.
She looked up, and for a fragile second I saw the younger face I had once loved.
"You're home for dinner?" she asked.
"Maybe."
"Promise?"
"Yes," I lied.
When I was broken, Genevieve left.
She left for warmth and for shelter. She left for a man who offered silence to her asking and money to the children of her parents. She left for what she called "security." He was twice her age, a man with a round belly and loud hands, and he wore the world like a sort of armor that said: I can buy anything, including the right to be seen.
I remember the first time I saw her beside him.
"You look different," I said, thinking I meant strong.
She didn't meet my eyes. "I'm all right," she said.
"You chose him," I said.
"I thought he'd keep me safe," she said, and then a line of words I did not understand: "I couldn't wait any longer."
"You left me in the dark," I said.
"You were in the dark," she said.
There was a video later. Boris Gallo—fat with his own sense of accomplishment—paraded her before friends, laughing like someone with a trophy. I smashed the man's head with a stool in a bar. I don't know whether I meant to kill him or just to make him feel the way I had felt.
The police came, the papers took pieces. For a time I tasted jail. For a longer time I tasted the hollow after she left. For the rest of my life I would imitate cruelty as a shield.
"I don't need you," I told her later, by way of demonstration.
She knelt and cleaned the floor until it could reflect a moon. "Carson," she said. "I made fish soup, like I used to."
"Eat it," I said.
"Are you sure you're not hungry?" she asked, worry knitted into the edges of her face.
"I'm fine."
Her eyes were full of something that used to be mine. She served me in a small bowl. The soup tasted like the past, a memory steeped in bones.
"Eat," I said.
She did.
"You're acting strange," she murmured, like a prayer that wanted an audience.
"Three million," I thought to myself, watching her. "Three million and she will be mine again."
There were moments when I could not help the cruelty. I liked to test her.
"Do you scrub the glass so people can see themselves?" I sneered once.
She stiffened. "It's not dirty," she said.
"No, it's you," I said. "You feel dirty."
Her shoulders drooped, and a small violence settled across her face.
She kept polishing anyway.
"I used to like that," I said hours later. "When you would fuss with the spoons."
She smiled mechanically and kept working as if self-erasure were a kind of worship.
I dated many women after I had money. They were all bright and lovely and disposable. Nothing clicked back into place. Armani, in her naive halo, came to my office and to theme parks with a clutch of dream-scented promises.
"Be honest," she said one day on the Ferris wheel, palms linked over the safety bar. "Do you like me?"
"You're fun," I said, looking out at the city lights. "You make me laugh."
"Do you love me?" she asked, the word like a small, sharp coin.
"I don't know," I said. "I know what I like."
"That hurts," she whispered.
"It hurts me too," I said, and I let the wheel carry us back to the ground.
One evening Armani came to my place, not knowing the history that hummed under the paint. She talked about books, about exams, about how she felt in a room when someone listened without judgment.
"You look tired," she said once, pouring tea for me.
"Business," I repeated.
"You're unkind to her," she said. "I saw how you spoke to her. You said things like 'are you dirty?' You humiliated her."
"She chose money," I snapped, unnecessarily.
"That doesn't make it right," she said quietly.
"She chose a way out," I said. "She chose a way to breathe."
"Is that how you forgive?" she asked.
The room held its breath.
"You're young," I said. "Don't mistake me for an ornament."
"Maybe you don't want to be fixed," she said. "Maybe you enjoy breaking her a little."
"How dare you?" I said, because in that moment she had walked too close to something I was trying to keep hidden.
She left. She came back later, crying, asking why I could have every woman but would not allow warmth.
"Why can you have them and not me?" she sobbed on my floor.
"You're only eighteen," I said.
"Then why do you punish me?" she asked.
I could not answer. I had learned to speak in the currency of humiliation, and sometimes it purchased the exact thing I wanted—complete, obedient silence.
When I finally bought my way back to Genevieve—three million in cash, a new car, an apartment that smelled like varnish—people said I had won.
"You give her that and she'll come back," Ulrich Duke told me. "Money fixes more than you think, Carson."
"Three million," Brody Coleman echoed. "And she'll be at your feet."
"Not like that," I said, but the thought carried a private ferocity. I wanted to own the humiliation I had not been able to endure.
I found her again in the way the rich possess animals—there was an exchange, a display. She came back to the house I had purchased. She cleaned with a mechanical devotion that terrified me.
"You're home," she said the first night back.
"Finally," I answered.
She cooked fish soup again with the recipe she had always used. I tasted the broth and felt a little of my childhood fold into itself. She served my dinner, folded my shirts, and stood in the hall tying my tie every morning.
"You've changed," I told her.
"I stayed," she said.
"It was your choice," I said.
"It was," she answered. "But I waited for you."
I would test her like a man testing the strength of a rope. Sometimes I would push her face to the wall and ask how much humiliation she had swallowed for me. Sometimes I'd hold her throat until the whole of the world narrowed to the sound of her breath.
"Did you do that for him too?" I demanded once, with malice sharpened by old wounds.
She turned her head and the room filled with a silence that was not only about pain.
"He offered better," she said. "You were poor."
"You left me," I said, because in the end, accusation is never about the past. It is about whether someone still belongs after the theft.
"He kept me alive," she said.
"I kept you love," I said.
She laughed once, a little sound that had no light in it. "Love doesn't feed a body," she said. "He fed me."
Our house became a set of rituals—her sewing, my meetings, her polishing, my absences. She embroidered a piece I would never understand fully, a square of work she called "Great Journey." She woke at dawn to stitch the fate of a life she had apparently been living alone.
"You shouldn't have to do that," I said once, my heart empty but growing heavy with a kind of particulars that used to be tenderness.
She smiled. "I want to."
She wanted me to be proud, perhaps, or to pause for a single breath and notice the needle moving between her fingers.
"Do you love me?" I asked one night, truly wanting to hear it.
"My whole life," she said, and I should have believed her.
"Even after..." I couldn't finish.
"Even," she said. "But I did what I had to. I was ashamed. I was scared. I didn't tell you because I thought you'd only be more frightened."
"Why didn't you ask me for help?" I demanded, finally crossing a line.
"Because you were gone," she said. "You were gone when I needed you."
I beat at the world in bars and boardrooms. I built and I bought and when the old memory of my disgrace came to me, I used it to humiliate her privately and publicly. I found erotic cruelty comforting, the way a man comforts himself by sharpening an axe.
Armani eventually tried to blackmail me. "If you don't give me what I want," she said with fire and youthful self-importance, "I'll reveal a few pictures and stories."
"What do you think those will do?" I asked. "Make me smaller?"
"They will make people see what you are," she said.
"People already see," I said. "They see a man who got what he deserved."
"Then what do you fear?"
"I fear boredom," I admitted.
She left, bitter and humiliated. I paid her off. Someone leaked a piece of gossip and newspapers sniffed at it and moved on.
Then the phone call came.
"Are you sitting down?" Ulrich asked in that soft voice of too many executives calling too late in the night.
"What?" I said. My suit was still on, the smell of cologne in my hair.
"Genevieve—she collapsed," he said.
I told him, "I'm on my way."
When I saw her body on the stretcher a week later, I felt like a man who had been given a photograph of his own life and then torn it.
"She didn't tell you," I said at the funeral when the room was full of people politely murmuring her virtues.
"She didn't want to burden you," some woman whispered.
"You refused to listen," said a voice I recognized—Easton Burks, who had known us both since we were children.
Genevieve's brother—an irresponsible gambler named Levi Mitchell—came to me at the wake with a face that had been squalid in his life and now was squalid with fury.
"You owe us," he said. "You used her. Now she is gone."
"You think I didn't know?" I wanted to yell. "You think I didn't see her knuckles bleeding from the needle, her face pale from long nights? She hid it because she didn't want you to pity her."
He spat. "You were her husband. Where were you when she needed you to be more than the man with the car?"
"I was the man trying to fix everything," I said. "I was trying to make a world where we could live without fear."
"By buying her back?" He jabbed a finger into the air. "You think money repays a life?"
The funeral had people nodding and murmuring. There were flowers the size of small tragedies. There was a coffin. There were words, and in the middle of them I realized I had been living inside my own sentences.
At her funeral, I touched the square of "Great Journey" she had finished just hours before she left this world. The embroidery was small and perfect, the stitches like a map she had refused to show me. Little red threads made a tiny phoenix, and her needle had been furiously working into the night to finish the last wing.
"Why didn't you tell me?" I asked the empty air.
"Because you would have wanted to be the hero," she said in the voice that was only mine now, the voice I had conjured from regret.
I had loved her in fits of violence and in fits of neglect. I had humiliated her when I wanted proof she still belonged. I had always been hungry for significance, not for the woman in front of me.
The funeral left me hollow. In the days that followed, guilt became a companion with its own habits.
One night I found myself in the same bar where Boris Gallo had once shown her off. He was there, public and proud, perched on his high chair like a misplaced vinegar bottle.
"He's alive," I heard someone whisper.
I walked over without thought.
"Boris!" I said, and he turned.
He grinned, broad and greasy. "Carson! My old enemy," he said, laughter like a bell.
"You paraded her," I said. "You humiliated her."
"She wanted comfort," he shrugged. "She liked pretty things."
"She had cancer," I said, because suddenly the truth was a thing that must be struck down.
"Didn't know," he said, insouciant. "I buy people flowers, I take them out. I don't sign their charts."
People at the bar were watching. Drinks stilled in hands. A few phones were already out.
"She died," I said.
"That's life," he said, and the crowd dissolved into ugly sympathy for his insolence.
I don't remember all the steps. Alcohol loosened me and grief sharpened me. I remember the stool coming down. I remember the sound of his skull under a wooden swing like the breaking of a piece of fruit. Sound is smaller than grief, they say.
People rushed in. There were shouts, the shrillness of sirens on the edge of the night, the hard click of shoes. I remember someone saying "he's dead," and the world folding into slow motion.
I had to create a punishment that satisfied the hunger of a life that had been hollowed by small cruelties. The bar became a stage, and Boris the actor who deserved the last act.
"Don't," someone yelled. "You can't—"
"Look what you did!" I screamed. "Look at what you took!"
Boris's face, for the first time, was not smug. It flickered—"I didn't know—"
"You didn't know because you never asked," I said.
"Bella—" he groped for a friend, an excuse, an exit. People started recording. Voices rose. The crowd became the loudspeaker of truth.
"She sewed for hours while you laughed at her," I told him. "You thought you entertained yourself. You bought her. You paraded her. You never asked her what she was carrying."
He tried to stand, his hands reaching for anything that could make him appear taller, more alive. "She was happy," he said, and his voice frayed.
"Happy," the word ricocheted in the room. "You're a liar."
Phones thrummed. Someone shouted "call the police!" Others filmed, their faces reflecting in small screens like a tribunal.
"Look at your hands," I said. "Look at them."
He lifted them like a man checking his own feet after stepping in something foul. "I didn't—"
"You didn't do anything," I said. "That's your crime."
Crowd reaction shifted—curiosity leapt into moral clarity. "How could he?" someone hissed. "How could he throw a person away?"
Boris's expression passed through stages: first denial, then a trickle of fear, then unconvincing outrage.
"You're nothing," I said.
"You're nothing but a man with money," he spat.
"No," I said, and there was a thin, terrible calm to my voice. "I'm the man who remembers what you took."
He tried a deflection, tried to laugh, tried to point at old favors. It didn't work. The cameras had fixed him. His friends shrank. A woman vomited behind the bar.
"She sewed for hours to buy a day of care," I told the crowd. "She didn't tell me because she didn't want to be a burden. You used her like an oddity for your amusement."
He shook, then fell. The physical punishment had been a match; the public shaming was the fire it lit.
"Look at him," someone said. "He can't even stand."
He clawed, his mouth making words that no one could trust, the rhythm of a man losing the last play of his life.
"Forgive me," he begged, and in his begging there was no repentance. The sound was a small animal's whine.
"Get away," a woman shouted. "Don't touch him."
"You ruined a life," I said, and strangers began to close around him with their own anger. The bar's patrons had been spectators; they were now assessors. People recorded. A hundred thumbs uploaded the violent truth to the internet before the sirens reached us.
"He killed her," someone cried out, though he had not. "He made her a curiosity. He let her hide."
"Call the police," another voice said.
He curled into himself. For the first time he was small. "I didn't know she was sick," he kept repeating, like a child with a rationalization.
"Then ask," someone answered. "Why didn't you ask?"
His friends scattered. One took a photo with a shaky hand, not of the dying man, but of the crowd. The crowd was the chorus and they recorded their righteous anger like evidence.
He tried to explain—too late and too soft. His face became a map of defeat and old decadence peeling away. People spitted insults and the clatter of cutlery seemed like judgment.
"Die with your money, Boris," I said. "Die with the things you bought."
He huddled, a greedy man with nothing to buy himself back. For a moment the bar was a courtroom with no judge, no bench, just an audience with flames in its eyes.
"Is this what justice feels like?" someone murmured.
The police arrived. Hands were raised. The footage later would show me smashing his skull and the shocked faces. The footage later would show his screams morphing into silence. But in the room that night there were people who threw bottles and there were people who tried to pull me away. In the end, the bar was a blurred smear of bodies and voices and the bright, clinical lights of a police cruiser.
Boris's punishment became the public punishment that the rules demanded. He had once used Genevieve as an accessory to his ego; in the final moments he became the object of the public's revulsion. He was exposed, small and filthy, recorded by dozens of strangers who would not let his image travel without the stain of his cruelty.
The crowd's reaction was a rough mirror to the life he'd led: first laughter, then surprise, then a slow, unrelenting consensus of disgust. His shame was no longer private; it was a broadband of condemnation.
"Why are people filming?" he bleated when men more determined than memory kicked him.
"Because we remember," I said. "We remember her."
When I walked away that night I had blood on my hands and someone else's blood in my memory. I felt nothing but a tightness that was very much like grief. The cameras would call me a murderer. The papers would call me a tragic hero. I didn't have language for myself.
Days later the town's gossip elevated the story into a thousand versions, each one angrier or lazier than the last. The law called me in. "You acted in a way that cannot be condoned," the officer told me, voice polite and in a uniform that smelled of starch. He did not know that the uniform's starch did nothing to hold the world together.
"I killed a man," I told the detective, because sometimes confession is a ledger.
"You assaulted him," he corrected.
"Maybe," I admitted. "I don't know."
A new cruelty settled in: people who once called me a winner now counted my losses like a form of entertainment. They said I should have let the law take him. They said I should have been better.
At night I sat with Genevieve's embroidery in my lap. I traced the tiny phoenix and the stitches. I said the things that are said at graves: I'm sorry. Forgive me. I would not hear an answer.
Armani's voice came sometimes on the phone, a timid sound: "Did you go too far?"
"Did I?" I returned. "What would you have done?"
"Stop," she said, but the word was small.
"Would you have sat and watched?" I demanded.
She was silent.
I had imagined revenge as a neat exchange: an injury repaid with equal force. But revenge is a dirty mirror—when you strike someone down you also carve out the place inside you that once held a heart.
At the end the law did what the law could. I was charged. People took sides. Some said the bar had handled a menace. Others said I had killed a man. My body, which had once been a tool of business, now trembled under public scrutiny.
I remember once more the evening before she left for the last time. Genevieve had put a bowl of fish soup before me and adjusted my tie, and said, "Wait for me. I'll be here when you come back."
"I will," I said.
She never came back.
She had stitched a tiny phoenix into a square of cloth, and in the margins she had written: for home. She had been saving what little money she had, scraping every cent into jars no one noticed. She hid the ache behind her hands because she wanted to be the woman who could make it seem like nothing at all.
I killed a man who had not understood how to ask. I humiliated him in front of others until he was small.
That didn't bring her back.
It brought something else.
"Would you do it again?" Easton asked me once, years after the funeral and the court and the headlines.
"I don't know," I said. "Sometimes I feel like I did the only decent thing left to do."
"And sometimes?" he pressed.
"Sometimes I think I murdered my last chance at a different kind of life."
He looked at me for a long time and then, with the bluntness of one who has seen ruin, said, "You had chances. You burned them."
I had loved a woman and I had used the price of my love to buy obedience. I had coveted proof more than presence. In the teeth of it all, I had thought money would save us. Three million bought her back, but it bought her like a thing.
In the end the embroidery was the only honest thing she left me. The bobbins of thread were like little compasses pointing to a life she had stitched in the dark.
I held the square up to the light and watched as her tiny phoenix caught a sun she'd never seen.
I could not put it back into anything. It was not a talisman; it was a map of the life I had failed to keep small and whole.
"Forgive me," I whispered to the empty room where her scent lingered, like lemon and laundry soap and the steam of fish soup.
Outside, the city moved on. Rich men bought younger birds and pretended the world was as it had been. Young women still admired me, sometimes with the same worship that had once made my chest swell.
"Do you miss her?" Armani asked me once, months after everything had burned.
"Yes," I said. "I miss what I had before I knew how to be cruel with love."
"Then stop teaching other people to be like you," she replied, simply. "If you loved her, let it teach you how to be better."
I do not know if I can be better. Some people are not built to change. Some people have already perfected their cruelty.
I can say, without satisfaction, that Genevieve taught me one final thing after she was gone. In her embroidery I found the smallest stitches of tenderness, the persistence of hands who kept making meaning even when the world grew too heavy.
She had finished the "Great Journey" for me, and in her last acts she was trying, in the only way she knew, to sew us both into the same patch of sky.
When the trial ended and the cameras left, I kept the square of cloth in a drawer. Sometimes, at night, when the house is quiet and the city allows me the small luxury of hearing my own heartbeat, I take it out and press my face to it.
"Forgive me," I say, and the thread answers only as thread can: mute and true.
I do not tell people about that. They have too many stories to tell, and the Truth is heavier than most can carry.
Lately I keep the fish soup recipe in my head, because sometimes the past tastes better when it is simple. I make it for myself and I drink it like penance.
"Do you remember the pink hairclip?" I ask the empty house, and for a second I can almost hear her laugh.
I am not a saint. I am not a monster for everyone. I am a man who loved badly, who tried to buy back the glow he had once been given for free. I am the man who punished a man for taking care of his own appetite.
Now, when I walk past the glass cabinets she made me presentable, I see only reflections—my own face older and tired and a fingerprinted memory of a woman who learned to erase herself.
"If there is a lesson," Easton told me once, "it's this: don't trade the living for the image."
I tried to live by that later. The price of that lesson was many things. I paid them with sleep and with silence and with court papers and with the slow closing of doors that used to open wide for me.
At night I imagine her small hands stitching the last thread into the phoenix's wing. I imagine her smiling at some small, private joke. I imagine the way she looked when she held the bowl of fish soup steady and lifted it to my lips.
"Eat," she would say. "It's all right."
I keep the square of cloth folded like a confession. It is my atlas of regret.
If there is a finale to this life of mine, it will not be in headlines. It will be the slow, quiet unmaking of arrogance. It will be the way I learn to stop speaking in money and start speaking in presence.
But I have already taught myself one mistake too many. It remains to be seen whether I will recognize a chance when it slips by again.
In the drawer the embroidered phoenix waits, and I sometimes whisper to it what I did not say to her while she lived: "I am sorry. I am learning."
The thread doesn't answer. It never did. It just holds the shape of what was left behind.
The End
— Thank you for reading —